1

I might, or might not, need letters of recommendation for a PhD application in the future. My plans are vague, I am just finishing my master's and planning to work for a while before deciding.

There are just a few people who could write a letter about me that doesn't just say "they did well in class". I would like to keep the option of asking them for one, even after being out of academia for a year or two (still doing research as part of my job).

I would also like to know how strongly they would be willing to recommend me. I worked with them on only one project. Even though they gave me very good feedback, I imagine they might not remember me well enough to write a good letter if I ask them after a long time. We work in somewhat related, but very different, sub-fields of computer science.

Should I contact them now, without having a clear plan in mind, and ask if they would be willing to recommend me in the future? Is it just a waste of their time if I don't yet have anything concrete to ask for, or any precise plans or institutions to mention?

3

This is easier if you can have a face to face meeting. Tell them you are considering it and ask for their advice, and especially about your likely success. If they seem supportive, you can say that you aren't quite ready but would probably want a letter from them in the future.

For a supportive prof they would possibly make a few notes to themselves about what to say before they forget your face and accomplishments. Professors see a lot of people and some things start to run together after a while. But after the heads-up they are, perhaps, more prepared to write a supportive letter.

But it is much less effective if you have to do this by email or such.

And if they seem discouraging, then there is probably no need to ask, thought they may still have valuable advice about how to prepare yourself.

I've had to ask students, looking for recommendations, to remind me of a few of our previous interactions if it has been a few years since we last spoke.

1

I would be honest with them and tell them that you're considering applying to schools at a later time but aren't sure where yet and ask if you can contact them in the future. I think that would go better than just randomly contacting them a year or more later and may make them more likely to remember the request.

If they gave you very good feedback, then you'd probably get a strong letter from them describing your work on that project and class performance. The number of projects they worked with you on is less important than the quality.

Also, when you write to them, remind them of which classes you had with them and the project you worked on. This should trigger their memory if they didn't recognize your name right away.

Good luck!

  • 1
    Thanks :) Just a detail: I didn't take a class with them, and we didn't interact outside of this project, they actually are researchers in a national lab and not professors. I guess it doesn't change your answer much. – Hey Jun 3 '20 at 22:21

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.