10

It is discussed here that it is generally okay to apply for multiple jobs in different ranks at the same university, but I want to know is it acceptable to apply two different postdoc positions in the same institution at the same time. I think I remembered seeing somewhere that you are not advised to do so because these two professors may talk to each other and find that you apply to both of them. Suppose I have sent an application to Prof. A but did not hear back, is it okay to send another application to Prof. B even if they are in the same institution or should I wait for a definite yes/no from Prof. A before moving on?

  • 3
    It's worth specifying the context (e.g., which field and country you are in). In mathematics in the U.S., I can't see any reason why applying to two postdocs at the same institution would be a problem. In particular, I don't think applying to another position at the same university would be more like to upset someone than applying to another university. However, maybe this varies between fields. – Anonymous Mathematician Dec 10 '13 at 3:58
  • @AnonymousMathematician I'm applying for theoretical physics postdoc U.S. and Asian universities. I agree that if you change the wording of your cover letter a bit and do not call both professors they are the 'best' you've known you possibly won't upset them but I've never applied before so help from someone who's experienced maybe beneficial to me and others who may have the same question. – egwene sedai Dec 10 '13 at 4:49
  • I did exactly that and got offered a position at both places. – Stylize Dec 10 '13 at 20:08
  • Are you assuming professor from different universities do not talk to each other? – Kallus Dec 10 '13 at 21:43
  • 1
    Is it really necessary and effective in a cover letter to say a professor is the best? – gerrit Dec 10 '13 at 23:02
6

It is entirely reasonable to apply for multiple postions at any one time, even at the same institution, provided you do it appropriately. There are a number of considerations to digest, but pretty well most of what is discussed in your linked question is relevant.

The most important thing to consider is that the application you make is tailored for the position you are applying for. You need to be able to highlight what amazing skills and abilities you will be bringing to this partnership, and how it will benefit the project. You need to avoid a cold call approach, otherwise your applications will sound like spam. This means you need to change your cover letter a lot. It is likely, though, that the skills you bring to any project will be very similar. You are, after all, a product of your previous experiences. If you were to apply for two different positions, highlighting two very different sets of skills and abilities, I believe this could be to your detriment if this information was shared between prospective employers.

You need to weigh up the relative value of each position. If they are both about equal, then I would apply to both simultaneously. If, however, one was far more cherished than the other - one was your dream position with a triple Nobel Laureate with access to the best research facilities and guaranteed ongoing funding opportunities and endless publications and the other was with an also-ran professor (do they exist?) who publishes once in a blue moon, I'd probably hold back on the application for the latter, just in case.

However, if there are two positions being offered in the same institution that you are qualified and suitable for, I believe you'd be crazy to let the opportunity slip.

There is an added consideration in that if your two professors discuss your applications, they may realise the potential to be able to share your expertise. And let's face it - professors do discuss applicants.

No professor/academic/employer is going to be that precious to believe that they are the only person in the world that you are willing to work for. No, I take that back - I've met a couple who are like that, but you wouldn't want to work for them!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.