1

Is there an accepted order in which "List of"s should appear in a thesis?

For example, I have a section dedicated to "List of (Code) Listings", another for "List of Figures", and another for "List of Symbols". Is there a preferred order in which these should appear in the document?

  • 3
    What have previous theses from your department done? – Thomas Feb 7 at 8:14
  • @Thomas I don't think that it is a good question to ask. It sounds very cargo-cultish. – Federico Poloni Feb 7 at 15:44
  • David: please clarify if you are asking in which order the items inside each list should appear, or which one of these lists should come first in the thesis (see comment below). – Federico Poloni Feb 7 at 17:53
  • 1
    @FedericoPoloni I am asking about the order of the list of lists – David Poxon Feb 7 at 21:34
4

For Ph.D. theses, some universities (including mine) care about some aspects of the format in minute detail. They should have an office where such things are checked. Find that office and ask.

If the university doesn't care, then ask your adviser whether anyone cares. If your adviser cares, obey. If your adviser doesn't care but thinks someone else (with some authority in the matter) does, then ask that someone else.

If nobody cares, just do whatever looks reasonable to you.

| improve this answer | |
0

Ask if there are local guidelines. Check earlier theses. Go to the library, rummage in books in your general area and see what order(s) they use, select one that you like. After the above, ask your advisor for approval.

Don't overdo it, too many "list of ..." may look bad.

| improve this answer | |
  • I don't think that it is a good way to decide. It sounds very cargo-cultish. – Federico Poloni Feb 7 at 15:44
  • @Federico Poloni: I don't understand the use of the term cargo-cultish in this context, and vonbrand's advice seems perfectly reasonable for what seems to me a question that a graduate student -- indeed, even a high school student -- should know how to deal with. There aren't even established standards worldwide for which side of the road to drive on, so why would one think worldwide standards exist for theses style issues? In fact, I suspect that in many universities theses styles can even vary by department. – Dave L Renfro Feb 7 at 16:43
  • @DaveLRenfro I find it cargo-cultish in the sense that it suggests doing what previous theses do without questioning if it is a sound idea or not. The same bad habits may be propagated forever in this way. (Also, theses, by definition, typically are written by people with very little experience in scientific writing while they have very little time to polish them up because of deadlines). – Federico Poloni Feb 7 at 17:50
  • @DaveLRenfro Sorry, based on your comment I now believe I must have misinterpreted the point of this website. If Academia is not a "question and answer site for academics of all levels", then please let me know what it is. – David Poxon Feb 7 at 21:41
  • @David Poxon: My comment was perhaps a bit harsh towards you (it was motivated by vonbrand's downvote and the first comment) and it was probably too veiled a request for more context. For me, the missing context is why not simply ask your adviser, look through recent recent theses in your department (department library, department reading room, main university library, etc.), ask around to find out what your department/university's style requirements are, etc.? I imagine there are reasons, and it might help others here in providing suggestions to mention why these avenues are closed off. – Dave L Renfro Feb 8 at 8:47

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.