17

I've submitted a paper to a computer vision conference (a top one), and recently recieved reviews from the reviewers. An issue was that one of the reviewers provided an incorrect review (i.e., a review meant for another paper than ours).

At the moment, I do not know which Area Chair (AC) manages my submission. All I can do is to contact the Program Chair (PC). Should I contact PC about this before submitting my rebuttal (i.e., responses to the reviews)?

The context is that my advisor told me that if I contact PC for this reason, it might be interference. So I was kind of scard and this is why I ask a question here. Also, it might not be completely obvious to others that the review is an incorrect one (althoguh it is completely clear to me).

  • 1
    And what has that advisor of yours recommended to do instead? – Karl Feb 4 at 20:05
37

I do not know which AC manages my submission. All I can do is to contact PC.

Therefore...

Should I contact PC about this before submitting my rebuttal

Yes, or more broadly: use whatever contact information you have for the organizers. There is no point in rebutting an editorial mistake.

| improve this answer | |
  • 8
    Sending a formal "rebuttal" may cause even more confusion, if somebody (e.g. a secretary or administrator) thinks it came from the real author of the paper. You don't have a review to respond to yet - you just have some mail that was sent to the wrong person. – alephzero Feb 4 at 17:09
19

My advisor told me that if I contact PC for this reason, it might be interference.

Your advisor is mistaken. If you had contacted the Program Committee chair trying to influence the refereeing process - yes, that would have been inappropriate. But it is actually very common for authors to contact PC chairs, for a variety of reason:

  • Problems with the paper submission system.
  • Delays in replies.
  • Requests for clarifications regarding the call for papers.
  • Questions regarding the submissibility of papers
  • Requests for deadline extensions (not saying that these are granted though...)

so it's not considered inappropriate in general.

Also remember that program committee chairs typically don't referee/review submissions themselves, so you're not contacting the person who's reviewing your work, nor interfering with that review.

| improve this answer | |
  • Thank you for clearing this up! – jachilles Feb 3 at 22:31

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.