0

Do conferences ever reject low quality abstracts? I've never heard of anybody wanting to attend conferences and being rejected.

If they do screen abstracts, will they reject abstracts that are not of low quality but are too broad in theme? Will organizers give applicants a chance to revise abstracts?

  • 1
    Could you clarify more? The conferences I know may accept or reject papers, and the abstract is part of the paper, so it is evaluated together with it. – wimi Jan 18 at 10:19
  • 2
    In my field, few people submit conference papers, which are of negligible imporance compared to journal papers. Abstracts are enough to attend conferences. – feynman Jan 18 at 10:42
  • Can you link to one such conference. What you describe seems very foreign to many of us in other fields. A description that gives a hint about what happens. More than a "meet and greet" I suspect, but less than what happens at a CS conference, I think. – Buffy Jan 18 at 13:21
  • Most of the rejection are in reality acceptance as poster. This is how it works in practice in fields like physics, chemistry, material science etc. Not sure about other fields in which a poster is hard to conceive (for me at least). – Alchimista Jan 19 at 7:54
  • This question is essentially unanswerable without a field (or perhaps even conference) specified. I know of conferences where most applicants are purposefully rejected to maintain prestige, and others where abstracts are barely even type-set correctly. – artificial_moonlet Jan 19 at 20:23
2

Major physics conferences do not screen abstracts. Abstracts that are nonsensical are routinely accepted at certain very big conferences.

Small conferences may vary.

Physics conferences do not permit revision of abstracts.

  • 1
    Some major physics conferences do screen abstracts. It depends a lot on the conference. – mmeent Jan 20 at 7:01
  • @mmeent Like what conferences? APS March? – feynman Jan 20 at 8:06
3

Depends on the conference. Small conferences often accept most of things, at least to the poster stage.

In some fields, a conference is a place for researchers to meet, so conference papers have little significance.

In others, conference papers are almost as important as journal papers and its really hard to get an abstract in. Check ICCV acceptance rates.. ICCV2019 accepted 25% of the papers only.

In any case, I doubt any conference would accept an abstract without checking it first. One thing is having low acceptance threshold and another is not checking the abstracts.

In short: it highly depends on the conference.

  • 1
    In physics, conference papers do not have "little significance" because they don't exist. – Anonymous Physicist Jan 20 at 1:27
  • 1
    I see the question changed. – Anonymous Physicist Jan 20 at 1:28

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.