1

I am applying to graduate schools in the United States this year. I have research experience for one year in algebraic geometry. I learned a lot from this experience, mostly by reading papers, books, and doing calculations. I have produced no publication (algebraic geometry is a hard field). However, I have a conflict with my advisor and therefore can not include him as a recommendation letter provider. So can I omit this experience completely from my CV? would it be ethical? or should I mention it and risk the admissions committee drawing the conclusion that my research performance was bad and therefore reject my application immediately as many people here seem to suggest?

1

I see no reason to omit it. I see no reason to have the supervisor write a letter of recommendation either. They are independent things. You want the best letters you can get and they seem to be from others here. You also want to show that you have some research experience even if it wasn't sufficient to result in publication.

I assume you mean undergraduate research, of course, which is limited in time and scope. The limitations are, well, limiting in what can be done. With more scope you might have gone further, as you would be expected to do with a more open ended program in a doctoral degree.

List it, even list the name of the supervisor if he has some prominence. But have the letters attest to both your background accomplishments and the probability of your future success.

Most places would consider it improper to contact someone that you didn't include in your application materials. But if they do, and you are questioned on it, just be honest about the situation. Conflicts happen. People know that.

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    Does this also apply if this is the only research experience I have? I've just started a new research experience with a new supervisor. I think he is impressed by my performance, but I have been working with him for only 1 month. Is it appropriate to sk him for a recommendation letter? If he can't provide me with that letter, will the above advice apply? – quasar1 Jan 15 at 14:42
  • 1
    If you are in the US, it will be fine. Very few undergraduates have any serious research experience at all. Even a bit is a pretty good indicator. If the new advisor stays impressed he would probably be a good choice as well as willing. But choose the people who know you and can support your candidacy best. – Buffy Jan 15 at 14:47

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.