5

Suppose a researcher uses the application of another researcher's idea in his domain. Given that original researcher knows basics of his idea better, he may help correct any mistakes and give valuable suggestions. In this way, the quality of research paper will be increased. But at the same time, giving away one's complete unpublished paper to unknown person is a matter of a bit worry. In your opinion, should he ask for suggestion or not? If yes, what is a proper way?

8

It is perfectly acceptable to email your paper to another researcher, and ask if they have any comments or suggestions.

It would also be perfectly acceptable for him to not reply. If he does, the reply might be something short like "Thanks for sending, looks like a nice piece of work!"

If you do write, I'd recommend you do the following:

  • Keep your email brief and to the point.

  • Do not ask him to check your paper for mistakes. That's your job. If you feel that you can't do this on your own, then I'd suggest that you offer to make your paper a collaboration with him.

  • Don't try to be indirect, or hope that he reads between the lines. If you would like to ask him to do something, then it's good manners to do so plainly and directly.

You might also search for and read the many "Why isn't so-and-so responding to my emails" questions which (with good answers) can be found on this site.

Good luck!

  • 2
    Please note that if you do this, you eliminate that author as a reviewer for your paper when you submit to peer review. – HEITZ Jan 6 at 23:47
  • @HEITZ please would you like to explain What are pros and cons of this? It seems good that I eliminate a tough person (who is the founder of idea) from peer review process. Just guessing – Muhammad Ashfaq Jan 11 at 8:51
  • Depends on the reviewer. If he/she would find your work favorable, you might want that person as a reviewer and you can suggest as such at submission, in which case don’t ask for pre-submission reviews. If not, you’ll get some great critical feedback to deal with upfront while eliminating a potential detractor (and be able to put their name in the acknowledgments). – HEITZ Jan 14 at 7:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.