3

As an undergrad I posted an undergrad research paper on the arXiv. It was not very interesting at all and I did not try to get it published (I essentially only used it for grad school applications).

Since entering grad school I have completely changed my research area and I am now ready to publish a paper in my new field (that will be interesting to some experts). I have also changed how my first name is spelled (and I'm affiliated to a completely different university).

But I'm not sure how best to proceed here:

  • I can make a new arXiv account and post the paper under my new name, without linking to my past account at all. The only problem with that is if people search for me using the older spelling of my name, they might see the older account

  • I can post this under the older account, updating my name and affiliation there. The older paper will be there and frankly I am slightly embarrassed by it. I also haven't worked in that area in many years so it doesn't make sense to have it listed together with the new paper.

I was wondering if the people here would know what's best. My field is pure math if that's important. Thanks!

  • Heh heh. It may be a fake story. But I have been told that Feynman used to sit in the front row of seminars and do "dueling Feynman" with grad student presenters. They would refer to one of Feynman's papers to make a claim. And Feynman would respond with "yeah, but Feynman in x-y-z from year yyyy showed that paper to be wrong." Maybe you could set up some such scenario for your future. – puppetsock Dec 12 '19 at 21:47
7

I'd recommend your second option. As for being embarrassed by your old paper, you could alleviate the problem by adding, either to the arXiv's comment field or to the paper itself, something like "This paper is a report on an undergraduate research project and there is no plan to publish it." (You might also point out explicitly the change in the spelling of your name, so that people aren't confused by it.)

  • As far as I understand, it's not possible to add comments to already posted papers without replacing them. It would be quite awkward to do a replacement now after so many years and have it appear in the mailing list etc. wouldn't it? – user12005284 Dec 12 '19 at 20:36

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.