17

I own an article on Arxiv and I am not currently an endorser as it is my first paper. I want this article to be endorsed.

My supervisor is qualified to endorse it but Arxiv is asking for an alpha-numeric endorsement code. Where can we find this code?

  • 8
    This question is clearly on topic, even though it misunderstands Arxiv. – Tommi Sep 23 at 14:16
  • @TommiBrander I don't think "How do I use this web form?" questions are on topic. – Anonymous Physicist Sep 25 at 3:51
  • 1
    @AnonymousPhysicist The question is not really about how to fill a form, or at the accepted answer is not about that. But maybe you can write another answer to the question that points to the right form. – Tommi Sep 25 at 5:44
  • @AnonymousPhysicist This is not about how to fill a form but how to get endorsed. It appears that it helps to clarify the concept of endorsement on ArXiv. – A.Ben Sep 25 at 8:19
28

I think you have misunderstood how the endorsement system works. Endorsement isn't something that's applied to an article, it's applied to an author. It's a one-time process that some people have to go through in order to gain the privilege to submit articles. Others are granted "automatic endorsement", by virtue of, say, having an academic email address

So if you have already been able to successfully submit a paper, then you don't need endorsement and you never will, and you should just ignore the whole thing.

If you had needed endorsement, you would not have been allowed to submit your first paper, and would instead have been given instructions that included the alphanumeric code. You would then have given this code to your supervisor, and by logging into their arXiv account, they would have been able to use it to endorse you. Then you would have been able to go ahead with submitting your paper.

The fact that you are not an endorser simply means that if someone else wants to submit their first paper and needs endorsement, you won't be able to be the one to endorse them. You'll gain this privilege after you have more papers. But you can't speed it up by being endorsed by someone else.

  • 2
    "if [...] then you don't need endorsement and you never will" The way the dcoumentation on the system is written it is clear that arXiv reserves the right to restrict automatic endorsements to, say, certain topics. Not that I have heard of anyone who had positings in one category being required to get an endorsement to post in some other category. I suspect that they've retained the option to give themselves options in hard cases. – dmckee Sep 23 at 20:21
  • 1
    @dmckee I've had it happen when a grad student submitted a paper I was coauthor on to a category none of us had previously posted to (and thus didn't have endorsement privilege for). Though, I don't remember if he found an eligible endorser, or if arxiv moderators just decided to clear it. – Anyon Sep 23 at 22:19
  • 1
    I suspect a misunderstanding. It seems that OP is just a coauthor on a paper that happens to be on arxiv. OP still needs endorsement to be able to publish papers there and they still need to understand what actions should advisor do to endorse OP. – Džuris Sep 23 at 23:46
  • 2
    @Džuris: If that's the case, then my third paragraph explains what to do (change it from the conditional mood to the indicative), or see the last sentence of my first comment. – Nate Eldredge Sep 23 at 23:49
  • 1
    @dmckee I've needed endorsement when posting to a new category in the past. – Especially Lime Sep 24 at 7:38

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.