Traditionally, a thesis is assimilated to a monograph and comprises a unified body of work. However, with "stapler" theses becoming more common, I'd like to know if a thesis is allowed to comprise multiple unrelated projects.

To make the question more regional, assume that the country is Germany and that the subject is mathematics.

Indeed for the first few years, I have been working on several projects that had as outputs papers that are completely unrelated (except for the fact that they fall within the same broad subarea of mathematics -- really, one of those listed in the arxiv math section: https://arxiv.org/).

  • 2
    I think only your advisor or university can answer such a question. If you don't have an advisor, perhaps there is a "graduate council" or similar. Or a dean. – Buffy Aug 26 '19 at 13:33
  • 3
    But at some point the advisor will have to approve the thesis. If s/he is happy you should be fine, but if not you are stuck. Really stuck. Better to ask now than learn the worst later. My opinion holds no sway at your university. – Buffy Aug 26 '19 at 15:41
  • 4
    "My advisor can't be bothered by administrative questions of this kind" - this is not an administrative question, it is an advisor question: "Will you, my advisor (and by extension my committee), approve a thesis with this structure?" – Bryan Krause Aug 26 '19 at 18:26
  • As others have pointed out, this is really a question that only your advisor can answer. Nevertheless, stapler theses in which all of the papers are unrelated (except for falling under the same broad area, i.e., number theory) are not so uncommon. A lot of the time they have titles like "Topics in X" or "On A, B and C." – user109454 Aug 28 '19 at 19:29

This is dependent on your supervisor, the comittee and the referees (in the systems I know, almost exclusively the supervisor). Moreover, I would expect from any sane supervisor that they know the projects you are working on and at least warn you if you work too much on topics which can not be put into your thesis.

Most of the time (if your supervisor agrees) and you write an introduction outlining connections between the topics, you are fine. I have seen theses where the introduction was "We present some.papers in the area X, here is an introduction to X" and everything was great. It's just a formality.

| improve this answer | |