7

I did my Ph.D. from Germany where I received a tax-free fellowship, and now I got a postdoc offer in Bremen with salary range TVL-13. The 'Stufe' depends on the previous experience of the employee, but since I was not paying tax and was on a student visa during my Ph.D., will my previous research experience count in this case? Would be great if somebody could answer. Thanks.

  • 1
    Effectively the decision is in the hands of the bureaucracy and from what I have heard in similar cases, the answer will depend entirely on the daily mood of the bureaucrat assigned to you. You should ask your potential new boss about it as he might know what happened in similar cases. However the only big jump in salary is from Stufe 1 to 2, which will be reached after the first year anyway. – mlk Jul 2 '19 at 14:46
  • Okay, I understand. Thanks a lot. – T Nayak Jul 2 '19 at 17:52
4

In general, no. The previous work experience you can claim for a higher entry point on the scale needs to be relevant for the job for which you are applying. There are very general rules about this (since the TV-L covers everything from dishwashers to head physicians) so there is some leeway in interpretation, but the basic assumption is that the duties of a postdoc are different enough from those of a PhD student that experience as the latter does not count for the former. Time in education (which a PhD counts as) are also explicitly excluded by the regulation.

It might be possible to claim that even as a PhD student, you already performed duties of a postdoc (independently organizing tutorial sessions for a large class, say, or managing the IT needs of your department), but the usual case for a higher entry point is if you previously were on a fixed-term contract of, say, five years where you received your PhD after year four. Then you could claim the last year as previous experience for a postdoc position at another university.

EDIT: See also my previous answer to a similar question. In short, you need to distinguish between times which must be counted by law (which your PhD experience definitely doesn't fall under) and times which may be counted if argued for specifically, e.g., with arguments as in my second paragraph.

  • 1
    I can confirm this for Austria, too. – henning -- reinstate Monica Jul 3 '19 at 6:43
  • 2
    But PhD students in Germany are often also paid according to the TV-L E13 scale (although usually for a 65% position or so), so it would be strange to claim it has nothing to do with the jobs of a postdoc who are paid in the same scale. Of course this does not apply for postdocs with more responsibilities who are paid according to TV-L E14. – Pieter Naaijkens Jul 3 '19 at 6:48
  • 1
    Yes, but so are high school teachers and translators, so you can't just argue with the scale but with the specific duties of the job. I didn't say it's impossible, but you need to make a specific case for it. (The clincher is usually the education clause rather than the lack of duties, though.) – Christian Clason Jul 3 '19 at 7:04
2

The answer is a clear "it depends". For instance, the DFG has a document explaining this available here, where it is stated that this is decided on a case-by-case basis.

During the hiring process, there will be a form that you will have to fill out about your previous working experience. Feel free to list your PhD studies under a scholarship there as long as you don't make it appear like you were salaried. The decision whether it counts will be based on the information that you provide. If you can prove that the work you did was equivalent to salaried position (e.g., involving teaching and research, both with provable outcomes), this may work.

Bremen has the reputation for being a bit special, though, as they involve the "Personalrat" in many decisions during the hiring process, which most likely includes determining whether your previous experience counts, so the rules of thumb from other German universities should not be relevant for you.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.