5

Assume I am submitting my paper to Journal X, which rejected the paper. After making modifications I am going to submit the paper to Journal X again. At the same time can I also submit the paper to another Journal Y (which has a lower impact factor than Journal X). As the Journal X has rejected it the first time, I think it may be rejected again. So I want to publish my work anyhow in a journal.

marked as duplicate by Wrzlprmft Jun 29 at 7:46

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

  • 3
    No, don't do that. I did not and I was not aware that I have to submit the same paper to different journals! The editor of the journal punished me by blocking me for submitting in one year as far as I remember, it was a harsh lesson as I wasn't aware of it. – user103209 Jun 28 at 19:47
3

No.

You must not submit to more than one journal at a time. Most journals explicitly forbid this in their policies. The reason is that people agree to spend a significant amount of time reviewing your paper essentially as a favour and their effort is completely wasted if you then say, "Thanks but my paper was accepted somewhere else."

You must decide now whether to resubmit to the same journal or to try for a less prestigious one. Since you're asking the question, I assume you're a student: discuss this with your advisor! That's what they're there for.

12

No, not the same paper in two journals at the same time.

Either submit to X again or submit to Y.

  • But that means I have to wait again for 3 months for X's answer. What if the paper is accepted either in X or Y. After that can I withdraw the paper from other journal? – swr das Jun 28 at 18:26
  • 12
    Yes, that is what it means. Journals frown on dual submissions. Most forbid it explicitly. – Buffy Jun 28 at 18:28
  • 4
    To add a rationale to this correct answer: the reason why journals don't allow parallel submissions is that it eats up resources with uncertain payoff. In particular, several reviewers will volunteer their work to review your submission. This could hardly be feasible, especially for less than top-notch journals, if there was a non-negilible risk that the submission could be withdrawn on a whim, e.g. because the author found a more prestigious venue or because another journal had a faster turnaround. If you attempt to do this, you risk being blacklisted. – henning Jun 28 at 19:26
  • 3
    For example, for American Physical Society journals, the Editorial Policies include the line that the corresponding author certifies: "The manuscript has not been published and is not being and will not be considered by another journal while it is considered here." – Jon Custer Jun 28 at 19:26
  • Thanks for the answers. – swr das Jun 30 at 1:06

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.