I've been involved in the publication of a volume, as a collaborator. I did all the typesetting, among plenty of other things. After the publication, a few authors asked me to send them a PDF of the final version of their article. I obliged. Some other authors asked the same thing to the scientific editor of the volume, who in turn asked me to send her the requested PDF files.

I then learned from a third party that the authors who have received their article put it online on a well-known academic platform, and that there might be legal issues about this with the publisher. I told the scientific editor about this and asked her whether I should create new files with a publisher notice or something. She answered me to "please tell these researchers to wait a bit before putting their articles online", so that she can examine the issue.

There's no way I'm going to do that. The scientific editor is a well-known researcher, and these authors are well-established professors. I'm a PhD student with zero authority, who got paid for doing the kind of menial/boring work nobody wants to do.

How should I go about this? I'd tempted to just ignore the request and go on with my life, but I'm not sure this is the best way to proceed. I don't want to be in bad terms with the editor of the volume.

  • 3
    Perhaps the title of the question could be made more specific? I'm not even sure a journal editor counts as a "superior". – Daniel R. Collins May 28 '19 at 2:29

Your reluctance is understandable.

Write to the editor and let him know that while his/her reputation would have standing with these authors, your own would not. It does no one any good if your letter to the authors is sent but ignored.

Offer to write a letter to them, but for the signature of the editor to be sent officially. The authors are much more likely to wait given a request from the editor. Include anything you think needs to be said, but from the editor's standpoint, not your own.

An alternative, perhaps nearly as good, is to start out your own letter as "I have been instructed by Dr X, editor, to write to you with the following request and instructions...."

| improve this answer | |
  • Yes, a message that does not pretend to invoke your authority, but that of the editor, would make vastly more sense. For that matter, no need to make it depend on your personal authority: you're just the messenger. – paul garrett May 28 '19 at 0:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.