1

I have submitted my paper on 12-Jan-2019. The journal uses ScholarOne Manuscripts for online submission. The status has been changed to Awaiting Reviewer Scores in the same week I created the submission.

I've recently contacted the editor about the status of the manuscript on 8-Apr-2019 and he replied that he is waiting for an overdue review, the the reviewer wa chased on 5-Apr-2019.

At this point, I know I should wait. But it's interesting to know if I can send another reminder and when should I do that. Especially when the editor actually reported what is going on and didn't simply mention that the paper is "Under Review" and I should leave it like that until a decision is made.

  • 4
    Field? It's relevant for waiting times. – Captain Emacs Apr 17 at 20:21
  • 1
    It's Computer Security – U. User Apr 17 at 20:57
5

You can send another reminder, but I would wait a bit. It is an uncomfortable thing to do, and my own level of discomfort with sending such notes usually gets outweighed by my impatience at around the 2-month mark. So, if you don't hear anything back by early June, you might write again.

But different journals and different fields have different typical timelines, so you will need to come to your own decision about the timing.

  • Mmm early June? Interesting! For me, when the editor said he is waiting for an overdue review, I got the impression that I may receive a decision pretty soon, because he only needs the reviewer to send the report. But I guess even one reviewer can take a significant time to finish. At worst case, the editor will have to find a new reviewer to review the paper. Am I right ? – U. User Apr 17 at 22:11
  • 1
    You may well get a decision pretty soon. I'm just saying that if you don't, it seems reasonable to me to ping them again in about 2 months. In my field reviews can take 6 months or more, although many journals are trying hard to bring that time down to ~3 months. – LarrySnyder610 Apr 17 at 22:38
  • Let's hope I get a positive decision pretty soon. Thank you very much! – U. User Apr 17 at 22:40

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.