5

I have published a paper last year (with other colleagues) where, among other things, we demonstrated a certain formula.

Recently another paper, independently, demonstrated basically the same formula but in a more abstract language and which applied to a much more general case. We are not cited in their paper.

I don't think their intentions were wrong at all, probably they were just unaware of our work. They certainly did not ''plagiarize'' us, but I feel that we should appear at least in a footnote or something.

My question is: what is the most polite way to write to them asking to be cited? If it's acceptable to do this in the fist place.

15

Citations are mostly to establish and credit where ideas came from rather than to establish priority. Simultaneous or independent discoveries are fairly common.

It's appropriate to contact the other authors and let them know about your work. Be polite and friendly, you don't need to accuse and shouldn't request anything.

The script would be something like:

Dr. PurpleElephant, I saw your recent publication in the Journal of Pachyderm Studies and thought you would be interested in our similar work last year published in Colorful Mammals (citation/DOI link). It looks like you found a more general case of ours...

And add whatever pleasantries or commentary is appropriate (for example, if you liked some aspects of their approach, or you want to point out something unique in yours). Hopefully you'll get a friendly letter back, maybe they'll be sorry they missed your work.

Note that this will almost certainly not get you cited in their current work which is already published (possibly it would be different for a preprint), but if they refer to their paper in the future they may also refer to yours. In case of some truly substantial simultaneous discovery, some other venue might be appropriate to draw attention to it, but that doesn't seem to be the case here: sometimes we end up on similar perches from standing on the shoulders of the same giants.

  • It is a preprint at this stage, yes. Thanks for your answer. – BlueElephant Apr 11 at 23:48

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.