I am a 2nd year PhD student and I have passed all prelims. However, I am facing a problem: I may not be able to get an adviser.

There were several potential advisers I was trying to approach. One of them suddenly left, others are either "do not know anything about my topic", "too busy to take a student", or simply ignored me at all (It seems that they were always not in their offices, and they simply ignored my emails.) And now I have trying my last shot on one of the faculties, but it seems that (s)he is not willing to take me and (s)he claimed that (s)he may not be a good adviser.

I talked with my friends and we got possible solutions. However, I am not sure if they are good or possible. So I would like to get some advice here:

(1) Switch field:

(I tried approaching all faculties with similar interest.) The problem is I know nothing about their fields and I didn't take any basic courses related to these fields. So the two problems are: (a) I know nothing, is it too late to start over now? (b) To be honest I am not interested in these fields. However if I stay here I think I need to switch my field probably. Is it really a good idea because I may need to face something I don't like for 3 to 4 years.

(2) Staying in my school and try to get an adviser elsewhere:

Is it hard to do so given that I am not a brilliant student? Since they do not have the burden to take a student from somewhere else. If I approach them, how should I explain my situation? Since there are some faculties working on my field.

(3) Transfer to another school:

If I am going to apply another school, how will they think of me? Will they think I have no adviser because I am dumb? Or will they think I may end up without an adviser again?

Also, in general, do I have to restart everything again? (Including the prelims.) I know that some schools will force their student taking the prelim courses irrespective to their background, in this case, I think I will waste time on the same material.

[Added] And one more problem for (3) is I doubt I can get 3 reference letters again...[/Added]

Finally, is it good idea to reapply those school who accepted me before?

Do you have another possible solution? And how do you think about these solutions? And if it is field dependent, do you mind indicating which field you are talking about?

Sorry about my poor language and thanks a lot.

  • 7
    Talk to the department chair and the graduate coordinator of the department, not random folks on the internet...
    – Jon Custer
    Mar 22 '19 at 18:14
  • I would like to collect as many possibilities before going to the graduate director as I do not want to bother him/her too much. I asked him/her too many questions before and I felt (s)he is annoyed already.
    – E.G.
    Mar 22 '19 at 18:26
  • What's the country and field? In mine, it's impossible to even start a PhD without an advisor, so it's unimaginable for me that you're in your 2nd year and still don't have an advisor.
    – user68958
    Mar 22 '19 at 21:58
  • My advisor changed schools in the middle of my degree. I felt fortunate that he wanted to keep working with me, but the logistics were really difficult. I really don't recommend doing this.
    – Kathy
    Mar 22 '19 at 22:55
  • @corey979 It is very common for my field that you are admitted without an adviser. And one more funny thing are some 3rd-years in my school have no adviser as well.
    – E.G.
    Mar 23 '19 at 0:24

I think that your best option is the first, but that is based on my personal preference and may not be yours. So let me explain.

Many students choose an advisor late and are then guided by ideas of the advisor. There is nothing wrong with that.

Finding an advisor at another school will cause lots of complications both in the short term and in getting everything finished up.

Moving to another school may not find you an advisor for "your topic" in any case. It will require a new advisor.

As a student, your short term goal is to get a degree and then move on. There is nothing to prevent you from then going back to your original ideas and developing them. There is nothing but time and hard work to keeping your hand in on those ideas so that you don't get too far out of the current loop if the topic is popular.

To expand on the first choice, I would choose a highly regarded advisor who has a lot of ideas. Work with him/her on something that is as close as you can get to what you really want to do, but, primarily, work to finish and move on. Your career will last beyond your student days, but you have to get there first.

I didn't have an advisor (in math) until about your stage.

I'll note that there is another option that may be open to you. I mention it for completeness, but it is a difficult path to follow. Some students work without much of any advice from an advisor, being very self directed. They need a formal signature and some letters at the end, but the behavior during the course of studies is more like that of a colleague, rather than as a student. You need to arrange this sort of relationship in advance, of course, but it works for some.

  • "work to finish and move on" do you mean I should forget looking for a research position in this way? and the remaining faculties are working on topic completely different from my interest...I doubt I could find something that both of us are interested
    – E.G.
    Mar 22 '19 at 19:19
  • 4
    @E.G. You've made a bit of a mistake if you have such a narrow focus of topic that you've chosen a university that has no one interested in your topic for graduate school.
    – Bryan Krause
    Mar 22 '19 at 19:32
  • 1
    Estimate the time it would take you under the various options. I will guess that choosing a different topic for now is the quickest. The others would seem to need a start up period.
    – Buffy
    Mar 22 '19 at 19:45
  • 1
    My field was math. At the time I picked an advisor I had a fairly good knowledge of the larger field (Analysis), but none, really about the specific topic. But the background made it possible to move into it. Perhaps your field is similar, but if it is too different, maybe my advice won't hold up. It wasn't like moving from Analysis to Algebra, for example. That would have been very difficult.
    – Buffy
    Mar 22 '19 at 20:14
  • 3
    Is there any chance you can follow your old advisor to the new place? H/She might be able to facilitate it if the other conditions allow.
    – Buffy
    Mar 22 '19 at 20:27

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.