4

I truly believe in the benefits of pre-print distribution, however I'm not sure how to exactly proceed. Here are some questions I have in mind:

  1. When should I make them available? Before peer-review? After camera-ready?
  2. Where should I publish them? ResearchGate keeps asking for my pre-prints, although most of the ones I read come from Arxiv. And there's always my personal website at the University.
  3. How do I handle versioning, or how many versions should I keep? Would that disperse any potential citations?
  4. What happens to the pre-print after the paper is published? Should the pre-print make a reference to the publication DOI?

I would specially like to know what's the "state of the practice" in Computer Science.

  • 1
    Should the pre-print make a reference to the publication DOI? some journals require that you update the pre-print and add the DOI. Read the guidelines of the publisher carefully. – carlosvalderrama Feb 21 at 0:33
6

The best practices I've seen in sciences, including computer science, involve

  1. making the pre-print available upon/slightly before submission of the manuscript to the journal/conference,
  2. publish the pre-print on the repository where the manuscript fits in thematically, i.e. where you find most pre-prints you read/cite (like arXiv oder Zenodo), or use your institutional repository, and
  3. update the pre-print with the post-print (the version after peer-review but without the journal/conference layout) if allowed by the journal/conference, so that you have one or two versions available.

You can check whether you're allowed to update you pre-print with the post-print in Sherpa/RoMEO, on the journal/conference webside or in the copyright transfer agreement you have to sign upon acceptance. There is also statet what other conditions apply, e.g. whether a link to the published version is necessary or you have to use a specific licence and so on.

  • 1
    About point 1: you may want to avoid doing this if the review process is double-blind (in which case making the pre-print available when receiving the paper is accepted could be a reasonable alternative) – user53923 Feb 21 at 10:40

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.