1

How understanding are American Top-10 universities of different expectations abroad? In the UK, nearly nobody publishes anything before they start their PhD. The master courses are much shorter and usually include mostly courses instead of research. We are not expected to do any teaching. I am therefore wondering whether all of this will count against a UK student applying to the US. Personally, I have a very good profile for a UK student (Top of my class in undergrad and masters), but I only have 2 research internships outside of my courses. Is it expected of UK students to achieve the same things as US students applying to the same universities?

5
  • Applying to what? Graduate studies? Post-graduate studies? – posdef Aug 20 '13 at 10:57
  • Applying for a PhD. – Gavin Aug 20 '13 at 11:00
  • Are you at a well-known university? If so, then people at the US universities are likely to know and trust your letter writers. – Anonymous Aug 22 '13 at 12:57
  • The same as for any other country, I suppose. – Jipperzipper Aug 22 '13 at 16:39
  • 1
    One of the requirements is obviously English. For you, it would mean not to blush when somebody says, "Neat pants!" – StasK Aug 23 '13 at 13:53
4

This may vary by field; my experience is in mathematics.

Most US students start a PhD program immediately after finishing their bachelor's degree, so they apply during the last year of their undergraduate program. It is less common to complete a separate master's first, especially in the sciences where PhD students are funded and masters students are typically not. The first couple of years of a PhD program are usually coursework similar to a masters program (you would probably be able to skip some or most of these courses, if they are comparable to what you have taken).

Therefore, the US students with whom you are competing are mainly undergraduates in the last year of their bachelors program. At this level a few of them may have published papers, but most will not. They may have research experience from summer projects, summer internships, independent study or lab work, but it is not usually comparable to graduate research. Very few of them will have any formal teaching experience; at most they may have worked as teaching assistants, which usually means grading homework. Some of them may have taken a few graduate-level courses at their undergraduate university, but not to the full extent of a masters degree.

So I don't think you need to be concerned about your level of preparation or experience in comparison with US applicants. If anything, you should be ahead.

As mentioned in comments, at a major US research department there should be people who have either come from UK universities or have experience with them. If they are not already on the graduate admissions committee, the committee members will consult with them if they have questions.

Good luck!

1

If you are literally talking Top-10, you will be on equal footing with American applicants, especially with your research internships.

Below that threshold you may well surpass American applicants, as you haven't spent any of your time minoring in side subjects since school.

This may not relate to how well your applications fare, but the larger universities will be well versed in taking on Eurasian applications, and you should expect fair judgement on UKish criteria.

2
  • 1
    @Gavin, you might even find some professors at those schools whose Alma Mater is your own. There's a lot of crossing the pond in academia, especially among the higher ranked schools. – Jonathan Landrum Aug 20 '13 at 14:53
  • To continue on @JonathanLandrum's point, if you do find such profs (a) from your university, (b) within your field (biology, right?), anywhere in the US, you could approach them and ask how to best frame your UK experience in your Ph.D. application so that would be easier to understand for the US colleagues. (Addressing the US graduate admissions in their language would also signal that you have done your homework on preparing for the course of the Ph.D., is aware of the expectations, and ready to tackle the challenges.) – StasK Aug 23 '13 at 14:15

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.