-2

I am interested to work and improve on one of the research papers which published on https://www.casact.org/pubs/forum/ but I found out that, research paper published on Casualty Actuarial Society, CAS, E-forum is a non-refereed and not peer-reviewed by any of the CAS committee as stated in the E-forum. So, is it okay for me to choose a non-refereed research paper as my Master's thesis topic ??

3

This is a question for your advisor to answer. But in general, yes, there is no reason why you can't take ideas from anywhere you find them. You should be pretty sure, however, that if you want to accept the conclusions of the paper as your starting point that you can establish their correctness for yourself.

In fact, even if the paper is a poor one, it may still contain an idea or two worth pursuing.

Also, you don't know why it doesn't appear in a peer-reviewed place. It is possible that it is intended by its author(s) as work in progress to be followed up later.

But, first, ask you advisor.

  • The wording of the question (and the title) "choose ... as my Master's thesis topic" suggests to me that the plan is to write about that unrefereed paper, not to use it as a starting point for further research. (But maybe I shouldn't give so much weight to the exact wording.) And writing about that paper could mean explaining it, or refuting it, or various things in between. – Andreas Blass Sep 23 '18 at 15:07
  • Yes, of course. I don't see a distinction, however. The conclusion would be the same. Just do it. – Buffy Sep 23 '18 at 15:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.