I recently applied to a graduate engineering program at a university and was contacted by a professor who was interested in my application. We discussed the projects that he is undertaking and seems to think I would be a good addition to the team. A week after the interview, he reached out stating that he has instructed the university to offer me the MASc position in the program I was applying for, and discussed the courses he would be interested in having me taking and the total funding he is willing to provide for the program. I replied back stating that I would love to join his team.

My concern so far is that I have not received an official letter of admission from the university and I am not sure if it is practical or ethical to apply to other universities in the meantime in order to ensure that if things won't work out I have a backup plan.

My question: is this the right thing to do or should I wait for the decision to arrive from the main university I applied to?

  • 3
    If you haven't received an official offer of admission from the university, you haven't been admitted (yet), no matter what the professor tells you.
    – JeffE
    Commented Jul 10, 2018 at 20:56
  • Depending on the country, this can either be very close to acceptance or pretty far away.
    – virmaior
    Commented Jul 11, 2018 at 9:15

1 Answer 1


Not knowing the policies of the university and whether the offer from the professor amounts to a commitment or not, I'd say yes, you can apply elsewhere, but as you have given at least a verbal/email/whatever assurance, you can't accept any other offer.

I would make other inquiries somewhat discrete, however, so as not to cause concern should the first professor learn of them. You also shouldn't represent yourself as being entirely free to accept an offer in the interim.

But you can also inquire of the administration of the first university what is the actual meaning of the offer given and accepted. Can you expect paperwork to follow or is it still tentative? You have a right to know this, of course.

You could also, perhaps, ask this question of the professor involved, asking him/her whether you should keep looking or is it a signed-sealed-delivered offer.

You don't need to leave yourself at risk, but you shouldn't put others at risk either.

And congratulations.

  • Well, the thing is after the interview, I went to meet him and he showed me around the University. When I told him I had not received an offer yet, he took me to the graduate coordinator to ask what the issue had been. Apparently one of my references had come in late... but it did arrive before the deadline. Now the admission board is reviewing the application to see if everything is appropriately filed. My worry is my grades as I didn't do well in the first semester of my final year. I am still well above the minimum cut-off for the program but not sure if that will help...
    – Cirith125
    Commented Jul 12, 2018 at 13:44

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .