4

I am not prepared to give many details in a public forum - as such this posting will contain intentional generalizations that may be of interest to academia.se's research higher studies community help, in particular senior faculty members, if any.

I would like to ask for help in figuring out if there would be a pathway to return to the pursuit of a terminal degree sometime 2020++ in a field related to my accumulated research work and career credentials with publications and products. At present I have a major blemish in my overall academic record at my last institution based upon an off-campus incident several years ago which ended in a sentence in a felony case. At the time of my projected return as a doctoral candidate, the faculty committee recommended suspension, and the admin decided on termination after it became clear I had failed to report it per student policy. Elsewhere on Stack Exch. I have already described the good that came out of that research, and that chapter of my life is now finished.

Can I ask the community if there is any practical chance of pursuing a doctoral program again? If so, When could I approach that, and at what stage should I broach the subject to a new institution?

Thank you.

Added:

  1. This is a US academic industry question, but I would think my research area would be useful for academic institutions of major space faring nations.
  2. My felony is for a offense not related to any workplace or academic setting.
  3. I was in the middle of my doctoral program when the inquiry began. Over a year I was encouraged to continue by the judge(s) to try to conclude the program as fast as possible. I continued work for the institution throughout (I tried to quit after some discussion but was asked to remain while trial was underway and the outcome not known). A sentence was imposed with reduction of all charges save a single one, based upon the admissions I made and material I surrendered.
  4. After completing my sentence, When I attempted to return, I was found to have violated policy for the crime conducted away from campus but while a student, and also that I violated another policy as I had signed a form for a leave of absence using a made up reason to explain my projected absence, the day before I left to begin my short sentence. The ruling was split: faculty recommended suspension and admin recommended expulsion.
  • 1
    Can you link to your related SE question, or do you prefer that they not be linked? The reason I ask is that the answer to this question might depend on a lot of factors, including how far you were through your previous program. If you were a long way through the previous program then you might have acquired many of the research skills from a PhD candidature anyway. – Ben Jun 25 '18 at 3:55
  • You haven't said anything about what country you're in or the seriousness of the offense (was it a felony?) – Brian Borchers Jun 25 '18 at 3:56
  • 4
    Your statement of "which ended in a sentence" is very confusing—are we talking about a criminal sentence imposed by a court of law or is it merely the expulsion in the title of the question as a result of the off-campus behavior? The range of potential answers may well hinge on the difference. – aeismail Jun 25 '18 at 4:11
  • 1
    Do you know how your expulsion from the program is documented on your official transcript? Presumably, it says something like "Expelled for disciplinary reasons/" You can assume that any other program will want to understand something about these reasons before admitting you. – Brian Borchers Jun 26 '18 at 2:49
  • 1
    Also, would it be possible for someone to research what happened by searching using your name and the institution that you previously attended? – Brian Borchers Jun 26 '18 at 2:51
2

The felony itself shouldn't be a big problem. While university will often have rules that basically allow them to kick out students that commit crimes while in school, to my knowledge it is not common to ask incoming students about crimes they committed before starting school. To meaningfully screen for felons the university would need to require a criminal background check as part of the application, which is rarely asked for. Now some sources of financial aid may require that applicants have a clean record, but then again, some might not. In any case, you are asking about studying, not funding. Your former institution specifically might be committed to cut ties with you, so if you re-apply there perhaps they would not accept, but this is hardly an issue when there are hundreds of other universities you can go to.

However, wherever you end up applying, you will probably have to mention your past work. Whether you will be able to get away with only discussing your research work, and simply state that you were forced to abandon the program due to "personal issues", and if forced to elaborate, whether the committee there will be sympathetic to your situation, is impossible to predict. You will just have to try and see.

3

I don't think your goal is impossible, but it will be difficult to achieve. I assume that your past infraction was serious or you wouldn't be in the state you are in. You can do one thing now, and you must do another thing later, however.

Now, you can find ways to behave in a way that shows you learned from your experience, have paid for your sins, recognize them for what they are, ameliorate the bad effects they caused, and that it can never happen again. This is harder (even) than it sounds, as some acts might not be repeated, but an underlying attitude might lead a person to do other things, not exactly the same, but also quite bad. Narcissism, for example, can often lead to a lot of bad behavior of various kinds. Also, thing things you do should leave some visible record that clearly shows a change. Even better if other people can attest to your good character now and in the future.

The thing you must do later is to be completely honest with any institution that you apply to. It won't be enough for you to promise to behave better. But the things you have done in the interim should speak for your change without your comment.

Even then, of course, there are many who won't believe in your change. You need to make it real change, both for your future chances and for yourself generally.

Good luck.


Note that I mention narcissism as an example only. Lack of empathy is another. But I'm not trying to attribute either to you.

2

The easiest path is to apply as a PhD candidate abroad.

Whilst in the US and a few other countries & institutions there is a special demand for an official offence-free record, this will not be the case with so many others. For most international doctoral-degree programs you may not need even a recommendation letter.

Once you complete your PhD degree skilfully, this past issue will essentially have vanished while you will hold a new network of contacts for a new future ahead. Move on, physically.

  • 2
    Note that you should make sure a felony conviction won't interfere with things like an application for a student visa. – Fomite Jun 26 '18 at 22:43
  • @Fomite That's a very good point. Dependent on country of destination. – Scientist Jun 26 '18 at 23:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.