2

Let us assume that my prior coauthor plagiarizes our common work and is going to re-publish parts of it under his/her sole name in a conference. I see a preprint of the work on a well-known preprint-site; the venue has not yet taken place. I ran free plagiarism tools; they show between nothing and 20% (tool-dependent) coincidence with public sources that the tools are aware of, whereas typical "new" papers show up to 2%. The rate would go higher if the 20%-tool were aware of our latest commonly published work before the collaboration broke apart. The author made some textual substitutions (variable XXX -> variable YYY, function(object) instead of object.function, etc.) and set-theoretical replacements (functions into powerset instead of binary relations) so that the text formally looks different. The author added a tiny bit of new (though, frankly, mediocre) content.

  1. Does the prior coauthor commit plagiarism, self-plagiarism, or both?

  2. I would like to prevent the prior coauthor publishing the paper. Moreover, I'd like the paper to get off the preprint site. The prior coauthor and me don't speak to each other, so, contacting him/her is unlikely to help. Is it possible for me to actually reach my goal, and, if so, how?

  • 3
    I don't understand why you are trying to block someone using your results if you already published them. They just have to cite you properly and be clear what is novel and what isn't. Whether their new additions are sufficient to rate a new publication is up to the conference, not you. Has the prior paper you co-authored not been actually published anywhere yet? – A Simple Algorithm Jun 3 '18 at 9:29
5

Contact the editor and provide all the evidence that you have to support your claim.

Do not keep going back and drip-feeding the editor with bits of evidence over time, make sure it is a complete package.

Also, consider the possible effect on you and your reputation for the future - if this goes the other way, how do you look...

  • In this case the editor is the PC chair. – JeffE Jun 2 '18 at 12:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy