4

Next week I am to hold a presentation in a master level course about kittens (a subject I knew very little about beforehand). I found an amazing book on cute mammals, in which the chapter on kittens contains all the information I need on the subject, while also containing numerous further sources.

Now, I am worried that if I simply rewrite the content of the chapter in the book into a presentation, I would be committing plagiarism. However, it seems senseless to dive into all these further research papers on the subject, when the book summarising it has already given me all the information I need.

How can I proceed to avoid simply plagiarising the book?

  • 11
    Plagiarism means using the material without citing it. If you use it, and properly cite it, then it is not plagiarism. It may still be disallowed for other reasons, but you will need to consult people there to find out. – GEdgar May 14 '18 at 12:59
  • 4
    Citing the source and giving due credit nullifies any claims of plagiarism. If by chance the material you found is under some copyright consider contacting the author to ask permission to use his/her material . – The Integrator May 14 '18 at 13:28
5

Acknowledge the influence clearly and appropriately. Precisely what this means will depend on the specifics:

  • If you use direct quotes, then show them clearly as such — i.e. in quotation marks, or some visual environment clearly marking them as quotations.

  • If you’re using figures, acknowledge this in captions: “Taken from Miaow 2011, p.73”, or “Based on Miaow 2011, Fig 12.2”, or similar.

  • If you’re not directly quoting text or re-using figures, but major aspects of your overall organisation have been influenced by the book, then add a note saying this at the beginning or end: “Presentation heavily influenced by Miaow 2011, Ch.12” (or “based in part on”, “greatly indebted to”, etc.) The bigger the influence, the more prominent you should make your note.

  • If your work will be advertised via an abstract, or similar brief description, and if the influence is particularly large — e.g. forms the main body of your presentation, not just one of several sections — then it may be appropriate to mention it in the abstract: “(This is an expository seminar, based in large part on Miaow 2011.)”

As long as the acknowledgement is prominent and accurate, then you are not plagiarising. However, a couple of related issues to be careful about:

  • In some contexts, there’s an expectation of originality/novelty in your work. If too much of your work is heavily based on earlier work of others, then it may not be considered suitably original or novel for these venues.

  • Copyright may also be an issue. I’m not legally very knowledgable, so take this with a large grain of salt; but roughly, I think it’s likely to be a concern if you are either directly quoting a significant proportion of the text, or directly reusing figures/images.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.