I am a PhD student that is about to graduate. Sometimes professors whom I know personally (and/or have collaborated with before) will say "Come work in my lab as a postdoc!".

However, when I approach them after a few days/weeks/months, they inform me they would like to hire me, but do not have any funding.

Personally I would rather they not have not said "Come work in my lab as a postdoc" if they weren't sure they would have the funding, but I understand their reasons for saying such things.

However, in future, how can I politely enquire how serious they are about how interested (and able) they are in hiring me?

  • 7
    I would interpret that sentence as "I encourage you to apply", nothing more. Apr 5, 2018 at 23:11
  • How can you see how serious they are? Ask them if they have or will soon post a job. On the other hand, my post-doc job was gotten in a very short conversation, when the director I knew of an interesting institute came up to me at a conference and asked me when I could start...
    – Jon Custer
    Apr 6, 2018 at 0:42

2 Answers 2


I would follow up the verbal conversation with an email. For example

Thanks for the encouraging words the other day about a possible postdoc. I wanted to check, were you talking about a funded position? Where would I find instructions for submitting an application?

Depending on the vibes you got, you might want to start with something less formal, for example

Thanks for the encouraging words the other day about a possible postdoc. I was wondering whether the position might be available for the upcoming semester.


Ask them!!! If you're having a conversation, and they mention that, it could be a serious proposal or could be a throwaway compliment. You could ask "I would be interested in that - did you mean it seriously?" or "I'd be interested - do you have funding available?"

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .