10

I am starting to put together my PhD thesis. The bulk of the thesis will be reprints of papers I have published during my PhD. I am wondering about presentation style.

My personal preference would be to reformat all of my papers into a single LaTeX document so as to have consistent style throughout. It's a bit of extra work, but I would prefer this approach. In several cases my papers have supplementary info which would not fit in the constraints of the main manuscript in the published version, but which could (and probably should) be coherently woven into the main text.

Are these acceptable options? Assuming I get reprint permission from the publishers, is it acceptable to change or partially reorganize the text for the sake of a coherent narrative within the context of the larger thesis? Or do copyright laws require that my reprints be exact reproductions of both content and style as compared to published versions?

  • 2
    Years ago I received a copy of a Danish thesis. There was a cover sheet with the thesis title, author, university, etc., and stapled behind it was a half dozen reprints of journal articles. Sadly, I did not manage to emulate that, since my university did not approve of it. Sigh. – Jon Custer Mar 21 '18 at 14:30
  • 2
    I mean, on the one hand nobody is ever going to read it again so who really cares how it looks, but on the other that seems like a cheap way to do something you put 4+ years of your life into. – KBriggs Mar 21 '18 at 14:35
  • 2
    @KBriggs - the 4+ years was to do the work and get the PhD, not to have a beautifully formatted thesis that sits on your (and your parent's) shelf. In physics/materials science people read the papers, not the thesis. Other fields may be different... – Jon Custer Mar 21 '18 at 14:51
  • 1
    Re. the copyright question, this may be of interest: academia.stackexchange.com/questions/71135/… In most countries, use of copyright materials in a thesis is permitted via statutory exceptions to copyright. However, this could limit your ability to publish your thesis as a book (common in some countries, I think) or to distribute it online. Making sure you meet your institution's rules on self-plagiarism is probably more important than copyright, in your case. – Wandering Chemist Mar 21 '18 at 15:05
  • 13
    Maybe an extra week or two to translate my papers into LaTeX and get the references right. – I am so grateful to be in a field where papers are written in LaTeX from the beginning. For me, the respective process took about an hour. – Wrzlprmft Mar 21 '18 at 15:09
19

I disagree with part of the other answer, in that the copyright holder of a work is not always the creators/authors. For some journals when you publish with them and sign the licensing agreement, you transfer the copyright of your work to the publisher. Then it is up to the publisher to decide how you can reuse your paper. I would advice reviewing the copyright/licensing agreement you signed with your publisher for limitations for reuse, and if still in doubt, contact the publisher.

  • Good point. I will check carefully with the journals I have published in, thanks. – KBriggs Mar 21 '18 at 15:26
  • 6
    @KBriggs Yes, this answer is better guidance than the other. Note that many journals have explicit allowances for their material to be included in a thesis, since this is a very common issue. – Bryan Krause Mar 21 '18 at 16:54
  • 1
    It's the norm for journals to take copyright, there are a lot of good legal reasons for that to happen (and perhaps counterintuitively, good reasons for you as well as for them). They usually release back certain rights to you in the process, though, which often covers just about anything you'd want anyways: inclusion in a thesis, distribution of your own copies of the work, etc. – Bryan Krause Mar 21 '18 at 17:39
  • 2
    @KBriggs This answer sounds correct for the U.S. Further, librarians at your institution may help you navigate this process for your country AND university--this was part of a dissertation workshop that I attended. – cactus_pardner Mar 21 '18 at 20:18
  • 1
    @cactus_pardner good suggestion, I will look into that. FYI, I am in Canada. – KBriggs Mar 21 '18 at 20:21
2

Checking with publisher was mentioned, but not how. Factually all large publishers have this "Request permissions" link directly on the page with the paper. Basically, you click on the DOI of your paper and search for this link. Then you are taken to another website, typically copyright.com. There you have to make some choices, such as "yes, I am the author", "no, it's for the thesis", "yes, all the paper", "no, I won't translate". Finally, a price tag pops up. It is typically 0 Euro/US$/whatever, but I've also seen larger values. You agree (or pay, if you are unlucky), then you receive an email that you officially may use this paper for the purposes you stated. Rinse, repeat.

Small publishers typically state the availability of the papers somewhere close to their front page.

If you have not signed the copyright transfer form yet (i.e., the paper is not finally accepted), you are good. If the paper is Open Access (i.e., licensed under CC-BY or similar), you are good. If you have not transferred the copyright, but licensed the content (say, to ACM), you should be good, but better ask via the above copyright.com process.

example clearence answer

8

As stated in the accepted answer, you should check with the publisher. However, this issue is often clarified specifically online. For example, AIP Publishing states on their website:

Q: May I include my AIP Publishing article in my thesis or dissertation?

AIP Publishing permits authors to include their published articles in a thesis or dissertation. It is understood that the thesis or dissertation may be published in print and/or electronic form and offered for sale on demand, as well as included in a university’s repository. Formal permission from AIP Publishing is not needed. If the university requires written permission, however, we are happy to supply it.

  • 2
    The same is also true for Springer: "Author retains the right to use his/her Contribution for his/her further scientific career by including the final published paper in his/her dissertation or doctoral thesis provided acknowledgment is given to the original source of publication." Source – mrp Mar 21 '18 at 21:23
-4

Just prepare your thesis the way you see fit and don't think too much about publishers or copyrights.

  • 3
    This seems like a recipe for a lot of frustration – KBriggs Mar 21 '18 at 18:08
  • @KBriggs This answer is actually fine - so long as your thesis is only ever seen by yourself, your supervisor, and your examiners, and you do not make it public in any way. However, since you presumably do want to make your thesis public, the "just ignore the law" advice in this answer is truly terrible. – E.P. Mar 21 '18 at 21:50
  • @E.P. Not it is not. Often universities have a specialized office taking care of the thesis formalities. I had to provide for each paper in mine a formal authorization from the publishers. – Zenon Mar 22 '18 at 8:20
  • @Zenon That's because you are making the thesis public. – E.P. Mar 22 '18 at 9:02
  • @E.P. I guess by university rules it is mandatory yes. I’m surprised it is not everywhere! Interesting thanks. – Zenon Mar 23 '18 at 1:42
1

Or do copyright laws require that my reprints be exact reproductions of both content and style as compared to published versions?

Why should copyright laws require such a thing? The entire point of copyright laws is to protect creators¹ and restrict what others can do with your work. In the sense of copyright law, you and your co-authors are the creators of your paper and you can do it with it whatever you want (presuming that you all agree on this). Of course, you transfer parts of what is included in your copyright to the journal, but for this you have to consult the respective copyright agreement with the journal and not copyright law.

Sidenotes:

  • Consider using the accepted versions of the respective manuscripts instead of the published ones. This is usually more compatible with copyright agreements. Also, this is closer to your work, as whatever the journal did to your papers is missing.

  • Your university, supervisor, and committee may have special ideas as to what you can or cannot do in such a thesis, which are usually more restrictive than copyright.

  • As already noted, if there is any restriction imposed by copyright it is that your co-authors should agree on this – which should usually not be a problem though.


¹ or in some legislation copyright holders, which in turn are the authors by default

  • 2
    Thank you. You're right that the university probably has restrictions; unfortunately, being a university, they have not placed these anywhere that I've been able to find them. Good point about using accepted versions. That's what I had to work with anyway so it makes sense. – KBriggs Mar 21 '18 at 15:08
  • 10
    When you transfer the copyright to a journal (unless it is open access), you cease to be the copyright holder. Copyright law is here to protect the commercial interests of copyright holders, not authors. Remember all the well known conflicts between authors of music and publishers/labels. Such music authors certainly cannot do whatever they want with their music and certainly cannot publish it independently anywhere else. Not without the label's approval. – Vladimir F Mar 21 '18 at 16:12
  • 9
    This answer is clearly wrong. The laws protect the copyright holder not the author. If you have transferred copyright to the journal it is theirs; not yours, and you do not enjoy special protection as the original author. – Jack Aidley Mar 21 '18 at 16:30
  • 3
    @Cubic: That's interesting, I'm no international lawyer so could you give me an example of jurisdictions where this is the case? – Jack Aidley Mar 21 '18 at 17:13
  • 3
    @JackAidley: Germany, for example. Also see the above comment. – Wrzlprmft Mar 21 '18 at 17:38

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.