0

It seems like the norm of American universities is that all the letters of recommendation are always positive stuff, and they are normally evaluated on the level of specificity they have, and if they have something extraordinarily positive about the student, rather than some usual positive language. Given that they never write a negative letter, would it help my application if I ask for a letter from the professor of a class that I didn't get an A in, if the professor is a really big name in the field? (I got an A-, so not so terrible, but the grades were curved and I still got an A-.)

I was also wondering if the answer to that question would be different for applying to European universities, given that their expectations from a recommendation letter seem to be different, and they don't necessarily expect a personal description of the students' abilities.

(The professor is a really really big name. He is one of the 3 most famous people in the field in the entire world.)

  • An A- is an A. This is not a reason to avoid asking someone for a letter. – user37208 Mar 16 '18 at 2:45
3

I think there are two questions here that help determine whether or not you should ask this person:

Do You Have An Alternative? : This may seem like a simple question, but if this is the only person who you've done relevant coursework with, etc. you might not genuinely have a choice.

Can They Speak to Your Abilities? : While in the United States letters of recommendation often contain positive comments, they don't have to strictly be about people who are unalloyed perfection. What is important is that the person be able to speak to your abilities as a scientist, your probably success in graduate school, etc. "Merely" getting an A- in their class might not mean they don't think highly of your ability to think critically about the subject, etc. - just as getting an A is not a guarantee that they do.

For reference, I ended up looking back at the people I had write my letters of recommendation - I had taken classes with two of the three, and I had gotten A's in neither class.

  • "Can They Speak to Your Abilities?" Often profs ask TAs for their feedback/drafts of recommendations, if TAs had more direct contact with the student. – cactus_pardner Mar 16 '18 at 0:20
  • I guess his letter will probably be a very generic letter, without mentioning anything specific. My only interaction with him was the times I'd go to his office hour asking questions about the course material, and occasionally questions after class, so I don't think he has enough information about me to write a good letter. Would his name be enough reason to prefer his letter over another prof without the fame and name recognition that I've done better in their course and talked to them more? – nra Mar 16 '18 at 4:33
  • @nra Personally, I read recommendations for the content, not the name on the letterhead, but your mileage may vary. – Fomite Mar 16 '18 at 6:17

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.