6

In this question both answerers suggest that papers in special issues are likely to receive more attention and citations than those in "normal" issues. Wiley have also made the same claim. Can anyone provide a source that gives data supporting or refuting the claim?

  • 1
    No data, but a couple reasons: (1) special issues often attract papers from top people in the area, (2) because a special issue is filled with papers in your area, people in your field are more likely to look at a special issue, and thus notice your paper, than if you publish in a standard issue. Because of (1) average citation data being higher doesn't mean a paper you write is more likely to get citations if you put it in a special issue, though (2) at least ups your chances. – Kimball Feb 15 '18 at 18:09
  • @Kimball A very interesting point that "average number of citations higher in special issues than normal issues of the same journal", if true, does not necessarily imply "your paper will be more highly cited in a special issue". – user2390246 Feb 16 '18 at 13:18
1

It might be pertinent to consider that the journal editors will undoubtedly commission their special issues in subjects that they consider to be 'hot topics', with the aim of boosting overall citations and of establishing their journals in those areas. So there's an element of selection going on even before you consider whether a community might respond more favourably to a paper just because it's in a special issue.

0

No source, sorry.

In general, there should not be any dependency. In some areas, the only citations you get are from people you personally introduce your own work to. The venue where the paper is published is of second relevance. In my experience, for example, my most cited paper is a technical report, although I do have journal papers, even published in special issues.

What might potentially play a role in citation counts is whether special issues enjoy free access or paid access.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.