2

I need to graduate this semester, my master's project is far behind schedule, and I'm not getting the guidance I want from my advisor. How can I work with him to handle this productively?

I have to defend my thesis in two months because my funding will be gone after this semester. I have zero data because my project is computer-based and involves an initial stage of bringing a simulation into equilibrium, after which we can get usable results. I've been working on this preliminary phase since June and it's still far from our "usable" threshold. In the meantime, I've been working on everything I can do without final data (practicing trial analyses, writing a literature review and methods section).

I'm getting only vague guidance from my advisor, who is admittedly very busy. He has a large research group, administrative responsibilities and outside collaborations, so I certainly understand that my project can't be his first priority. He told me that I have to graduate this semester. I've kept him updated about the project status and my current steps, and he says that is all "fine" and I'm doing the right things, but that it's impossible to predict when the simulation might work, and "that's just how research is." I've expressed my concerns more than once, and he's typically responded by telling me not to "over-think things" and not to "freak out." At our most recent meeting, I said that I doubt the simulation will be working in the next few weeks and asked what I should do in that case--he said "you still have two months, we'll just have to see what happens."

My advisor is well-established and respected in his field. He has a strong track record of graduating students, and he's certainly more experienced and knows much more about research than I do. I should trust him when he says everything is fine, but it doesn't seem fine to me. I can't realistically expect everything to start working in the next few weeks when I've made insufficient progress for eight months so far. I have no backup plan for what to do without the data.

How can I express my concerns so that my advisor will listen? How can I do better at getting specific guidance?

Edit to update: I did reach out to other students and postdocs for help on the technical issues, and I've been doing that since June as well.

Edit for how it all turned out: I talked again with some other students, and came up with a new strategy. My advisor was a little skeptical but agreed we could try it. Luckily the new approach turned out much better. He is still too busy to give the project much attention, but as long as I can finish the entire project and write up everything in a month (no stress, right??) I should be fine!

  • 1
    Sounds like it's time for a second opinion. See if there's another professor or more advanced student who would meet with you. – aparente001 Feb 10 '18 at 19:10
  • I did speak with another professor and the advice was basically "listen to your advisor and talk with him about your concerns."(Which I'm already doing but clearly need to do better) – Curious Feb 14 '18 at 17:23
  • Not all professors will go out of their way to help someone else's student. – aparente001 Feb 14 '18 at 19:27
  • Totally fair point! The professor I visited is in the graduate studies office and had recently emailed all grad students that we could come speak with him if we wanted any general advice. So I don't believe I was overstepping with the visit. – Curious Feb 14 '18 at 19:35
  • I'm not criticizing your choice of second opinion. It's your degree, and only you can decide how persistent you want to be. – aparente001 Feb 14 '18 at 19:37
2

Your advisor will not solve your problem - at least it is very unlikely! Digging very deep in the specifics of such a simulation is something a person in such a position just don't have the time to - and sometimes even not the detailed knowledge, e.g. regarding frameworks used, implementation details etc.!

One question you should adress is: Will (s)he accept negative results? If you can describe all steps you did, explain why things did not work as planned, do you still have a chance for a good grade? If "yes", then really everything is fine, you "just" have to work hard and document all your attempts.

If "no", you should try to get help from a graduate student or post-doc working in a similar field. But still keep your advisor updated about everything you do.

  • No, negative results aren't acceptable. I've been reaching out to other grad students/postdocs since June, and the consensus seems to be that I'm doing the right things....they just take a long time to finish and nobody can really predict the timeline. – Curious Feb 9 '18 at 15:54
  • so what could your advisor eventually do? It seems you are on the right track and things just need time... – OBu Feb 10 '18 at 10:35
  • I could really use more specific guidance about what I should do on the project if I can't make everything work in the next couple months. – Curious Feb 11 '18 at 17:08
  • Have you asked your advisor that specific question? – aeismail Mar 1 '18 at 6:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.