What I mean is, are there cases in which a professor might decline writing are letter of recommendation for a PhD program, but would accept writing such a letter for a student applying to a MA or MPhil programme? Is the professor seen as vouching for the student more, when he writes a letter for a PhD program than when we're talking about MA or MPhil programs? Or is there virtually no difference?

  • 2
    A professor might decline to recommend a student for a PhD program if they don't think the student can succeed. The same professor might recommend the student for a lesser degree, such as a MA or MPhil, if they think the student can succeed at that. – user2768 Dec 14 '17 at 15:38

There may be a distinction between how letters are written for a primarily course-based graduate program and a (presumably more advanced) primarily research-based one. However, in most cases, it would not be a great difference. Qualifications such as intelligence, knowledge of the subject area, and reliability/maturity are important for both types of graduate programs. Most letter writers would probably discuss these issues in similar terms whether the applicant wants to get into a course-based or research-based program.

On the other hand, there are differences between what a letter writer will emphasize when a student is applying to different kinds of programs. When a student is applying for a research-based program, it will help to have letters from mentors who have worked with the applicant in a research environment, and such letters will carry a great deal of weight. However, there are almost always going to be several faculty members who can write letters about a student's classroom performance, while far fewer (and often none) who can have worked with a student on research.

There are, moreover, some situations where a faculty member might have no problem recommend a student for one type of program, but be more hesitant to recommend a student for other programs. If the student has actually demonstrated that they are good in the classroom but have also demonstrated problems working in a research environment, a recommender might not feel that the student is not ready for a research-based program (like a British Ph.D. program) yet; however, this very seldom happens.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.