Episode #125 of the Stack Overflow podcast is here. We talk Tilde Club and mechanical keyboards. Listen now
4 rephrased question, to make it more clear
source | link

Doing a second PhD in a different (neighbouring) field in steadinstead of a Habilitation

I just started a 3-4 year Post-Doc position at an engineering department at an German University. The Professor herein Department A, informally asked about my ambitions to dowork on a Habilitation. I know that istopic on the common route at leastborder between two fields on which they also work in severalDepartment B.

In some European countries in the direction ofusual situation is to do a permanent faculty positionHabilitation in A. However the planned activities However, and research topics for the Post-Doctheoretically it is also seem suitablepossible to doget payed by department A, and working on projects for A, but doing a second PhD in computer Sciencedepartment B as an external PhD candidate (while my current PhD isas if i where in Mechanical Engineeringan external research institute), in stead of doing a Habilitation in A. Of course I would have to be Doing a "external" PhD, at an external advisor fromother place than the CS department, but i think thatsupervising Professor is manageable, since i already have some publicationsquite common in the field of one of their groupsGermany, Italy and some positive informal contact to one of the Professors therea few other EU countries. Also i feel confidentBut only if the other place is a research institute or company, doing that in another university group, or university is very uncommon/rare, especially when it is about doing a second PhD. I am not easily persuaded by uncommon/rare by itself, so i wont needwould like to much of their time for guidance since i already haveknow the experiencepros and cons of the first PhD.taking this unusual path?

My reasons to beHonestly only see more inclined towards a second PhDadvantages (more collaborators, shared expertise) especially for topics that are on the border between two fields. instead of aA Habilitation arecan easily be waved if you have enough publications. It seems to me that i think i will get bored of my current field in a couple of years, and the second PhD seems to give e a better chancein B will later make it easier to change fields laterto B, beyond only the topics on the border between A and B. OnOn the other hand i do not know any people who did something like thatthis. And i can not really predict the consequences or reaction of such a unconventional route. And i also do not want to freak out my new boss by mentioning this idea, if the majority of you would consider it as very inappropriate.

What are the pros and cons of extending your research field by doing a second PhD in another direction stead of deepening while doing a Habilitation in the same field? Are there any big disadvantages for the Professor of the department which employs me which i maybe overlooked?

EDIT: The current Position is in Germany. Although i would be interested in staying in Germany, i would also like to hear about perspectives on this for other countries. That also makes the value of the question more general.

EDIT 2: Since my question was maybe not clear or specific enough. Lets say there is the situation that one is funded by a Post-Doc position in Department A, to work on a topic on which they also work in Department B. So the question is about getting payed by department A, and working on projects for A, but doing a second PhD in B as an external PhD candidate (as if i where in an external research institute), in stead of a Habilitation in A. Doing a "external" PhD, at an other place than the Supervising Professor is quite common in Germany. But only if the other place is a research institute or company, doing that in another university group, or university is very uncommon/rare. Uncommon could imply that it is unnecessary, but rare could also be valuable. Therefore like to know what are the potential problems? Because i only see advantages (more collaborators, shared expertise) especially for topics that are on the border between two fields.

Doing a second PhD in a different (neighbouring) field in stead of Habilitation

I just started a 3 year Post-Doc position at an engineering department at an German University. The Professor here, informally asked about my ambitions to do a Habilitation. I know that is the common route at least in several European countries in the direction of a permanent faculty position. However the planned activities, and research topics for the Post-Doc also seem suitable to do a second PhD in computer Science (while my current PhD is in Mechanical Engineering). Of course I would have to be an external advisor from the CS department, but i think that is manageable, since i already have some publications in the field of one of their groups and some positive informal contact to one of the Professors there. Also i feel confident that i wont need to much of their time for guidance since i already have the experience of the first PhD.

My reasons to be more inclined towards a second PhD. instead of a Habilitation are that i think i will get bored of my current field in a couple of years, and the second PhD seems to give e a better chance to change fields later. On the other hand i do not know any people who did something like that. And i can not really predict the consequences or reaction of such a unconventional route. And i also do not want to freak out my new boss by mentioning this idea, if the majority of you would consider it as very inappropriate.

What are the pros and cons of extending your research field by doing a second PhD in another direction stead of deepening while doing a Habilitation in the same field? Are there any big disadvantages for the Professor of the department which employs me which i maybe overlooked?

EDIT: The current Position is in Germany. Although i would be interested in staying in Germany, i would also like to hear about perspectives on this for other countries. That also makes the value of the question more general.

EDIT 2: Since my question was maybe not clear or specific enough. Lets say there is the situation that one is funded by a Post-Doc position in Department A, to work on a topic on which they also work in Department B. So the question is about getting payed by department A, and working on projects for A, but doing a second PhD in B as an external PhD candidate (as if i where in an external research institute), in stead of a Habilitation in A. Doing a "external" PhD, at an other place than the Supervising Professor is quite common in Germany. But only if the other place is a research institute or company, doing that in another university group, or university is very uncommon/rare. Uncommon could imply that it is unnecessary, but rare could also be valuable. Therefore like to know what are the potential problems? Because i only see advantages (more collaborators, shared expertise) especially for topics that are on the border between two fields.

Doing a second PhD in different field instead of a Habilitation

I just started a 3-4 year Post-Doc position in Department A, to work on a topic on the border between two fields on which they also work in Department B.

In some European countries the usual situation is to do a Habilitation in A. However, theoretically it is also possible to get payed by department A, and working on projects for A, but doing a second PhD department B as an external PhD candidate (as if i where in an external research institute), in stead of doing a Habilitation in A. Doing a "external" PhD, at an other place than the supervising Professor is quite common in Germany, Italy and a few other EU countries. But only if the other place is a research institute or company, doing that in another university group, or university is very uncommon/rare, especially when it is about doing a second PhD. I am not easily persuaded by uncommon/rare by itself, so i would like to know the pros and cons of taking this unusual path?

Honestly only see more advantages (more collaborators, shared expertise) especially for topics that are on the border between two fields. A Habilitation can easily be waved if you have enough publications. It seems to me that a second PhD in B will later make it easier to change fields to B, beyond only the topics on the border between A and B. On the other hand i do not know any people who did something like this. And i can not really predict the consequences or reaction of such a unconventional route. And i also do not want to freak out my new boss by mentioning this idea, if the majority of you would consider it as very inappropriate.

What are the pros and cons of extending your research field by doing a second PhD in another direction stead of deepening while doing a Habilitation in the same field?

EDIT: The current Position is in Germany. Although i would be interested in staying in Germany, i would also like to hear about perspectives on this for other countries. That also makes the value of the question more general.

3 more detailed explanation
source | link

I just started a 3 year Post-Doc position at an engineering department at an German University. The Professor here, informally asked about my ambitions to do a Habilitation. I know that is the common route at least in several European countries in the direction of a permanent faculty position. However the planned activities, and research topics for the Post-Doc also seem suitable to do a second PhD in computer Science (while my current PhD is in Mechanical Engineering). Of course I would have to be an external advisor from the CS department, but i think that is manageable, since i already have some publications in the field of one of their groups and some positive informal contact to one of the Professors there. Also i feel confident that i wont need to much of their time for guidance since i already have the experience of the first PhD.

My reasons to be more inclined towards a second PhD. instead of a Habilitation are that i think i will get bored of my current field in a couple of years, and the second PhD seems to give e a better chance to change fields later. On the other hand i do not know any people who did something like that. And i can not really predict the consequences or reaction of such a unconventional route. And i also do not want to freak out my new boss by mentioning this idea, if the majority of you would consider it as very inappropriate.

What are the pros and cons of extending your research field by doing a second PhD in another direction stead of deepening while doing a Habilitation in the same field? Are there any big disadvantages for the Professor of the department which employs me which i maybe overlooked?

EDIT: The current Position is in Germany. Although i would be interested in staying in Germany, i would also like to hear about perspectives on this for other countries. That also makes the value of the question more general.

EDIT 2: Since my question was maybe not clear or specific enough. Lets say there is the situation that one is funded by a Post-Doc position in Department A, to work on a topic on which they also work in Department B. So the question is about getting payed by department A, and working on projects for A, but doing a second PhD in B as an external PhD candidate (as if i where in an external research institute), in stead of a Habilitation in A. Doing a "external" PhD, at an other place than the Supervising Professor is quite common in Germany. But only if the other place is a research institute or company, doing that in another university group, or university is very uncommon/rare. Uncommon could imply that it is unnecessary, but rare could also be valuable. Therefore like to know what are the potential problems? Because i only see advantages (more collaborators, shared expertise) especially for topics that are on the border between two fields.

I just started a 3 year Post-Doc position at an engineering department at an German University. The Professor here, informally asked about my ambitions to do a Habilitation. I know that is the common route at least in several European countries in the direction of a permanent faculty position. However the planned activities, and research topics for the Post-Doc also seem suitable to do a second PhD in computer Science (while my current PhD is in Mechanical Engineering). Of course I would have to be an external advisor from the CS department, but i think that is manageable, since i already have some publications in the field of one of their groups and some positive informal contact to one of the Professors there. Also i feel confident that i wont need to much of their time for guidance since i already have the experience of the first PhD.

My reasons to be more inclined towards a second PhD. instead of a Habilitation are that i think i will get bored of my current field in a couple of years, and the second PhD seems to give e a better chance to change fields later. On the other hand i do not know any people who did something like that. And i can not really predict the consequences or reaction of such a unconventional route. And i also do not want to freak out my new boss by mentioning this idea, if the majority of you would consider it as very inappropriate.

What are the pros and cons of extending your research field by doing a second PhD in another direction stead of deepening while doing a Habilitation in the same field? Are there any big disadvantages for the Professor of the department which employs me which i maybe overlooked?

EDIT: The current Position is in Germany. Although i would be interested in staying in Germany, i would also like to hear about perspectives on this for other countries. That also makes the value of the question more general.

I just started a 3 year Post-Doc position at an engineering department at an German University. The Professor here, informally asked about my ambitions to do a Habilitation. I know that is the common route at least in several European countries in the direction of a permanent faculty position. However the planned activities, and research topics for the Post-Doc also seem suitable to do a second PhD in computer Science (while my current PhD is in Mechanical Engineering). Of course I would have to be an external advisor from the CS department, but i think that is manageable, since i already have some publications in the field of one of their groups and some positive informal contact to one of the Professors there. Also i feel confident that i wont need to much of their time for guidance since i already have the experience of the first PhD.

My reasons to be more inclined towards a second PhD. instead of a Habilitation are that i think i will get bored of my current field in a couple of years, and the second PhD seems to give e a better chance to change fields later. On the other hand i do not know any people who did something like that. And i can not really predict the consequences or reaction of such a unconventional route. And i also do not want to freak out my new boss by mentioning this idea, if the majority of you would consider it as very inappropriate.

What are the pros and cons of extending your research field by doing a second PhD in another direction stead of deepening while doing a Habilitation in the same field? Are there any big disadvantages for the Professor of the department which employs me which i maybe overlooked?

EDIT: The current Position is in Germany. Although i would be interested in staying in Germany, i would also like to hear about perspectives on this for other countries. That also makes the value of the question more general.

EDIT 2: Since my question was maybe not clear or specific enough. Lets say there is the situation that one is funded by a Post-Doc position in Department A, to work on a topic on which they also work in Department B. So the question is about getting payed by department A, and working on projects for A, but doing a second PhD in B as an external PhD candidate (as if i where in an external research institute), in stead of a Habilitation in A. Doing a "external" PhD, at an other place than the Supervising Professor is quite common in Germany. But only if the other place is a research institute or company, doing that in another university group, or university is very uncommon/rare. Uncommon could imply that it is unnecessary, but rare could also be valuable. Therefore like to know what are the potential problems? Because i only see advantages (more collaborators, shared expertise) especially for topics that are on the border between two fields.

2 added country
source | link

I just started a 3 year Post-Doc position at an engineering department a couple of months agoat an German University. The Professor here, informally asked about my ambitions to do a Habilitation. I know that is the common route at least in several European countries in the direction of a permanent faculty position. However the planned activities, and research topics for the Post-Doc also seem suitable to do a second PhD in computer Science (while my current PhD is in Mechanical Engineering). Of course I would have to be an external advisor from the CS department, but i think that is manageable, since i already have some publications in the field of one of their groups and some positive informal contact to one of the Professors there. Also i feel confident that i wont need to much of their time for guidance since i already have the experience of the first PhD.

My reasons to be more inclined towards a second PhD. instead of a Habilitation are that i think i will get bored of my current field in a couple of years, and the second PhD seems to give e a better chance to change fields later. On the other hand i do not know any people who did something like that. And i can not really predict the consequences or reaction of such a unconventional route. And i also do not want to freak out my new boss by mentioning this idea, if the majority of you would consider it as very inappropriate.

What are the pros and cons of extending your research field by doing a second PhD in another direction stead of deepening while doing a Habilitation in the same field? Are there any big disadvantages for the Professor of the department which employs me which i maybe overlooked?

EDIT: The current Position is in Germany. Although i would be interested in staying in Germany, i would also like to hear about perspectives on this for other countries. That also makes the value of the question more general.

I just started a 3 year Post-Doc position at an engineering department a couple of months ago. The Professor here, informally asked about my ambitions to do a Habilitation. I know that is the common route at least in several European countries in the direction of a permanent faculty position. However the planned activities, and research topics for the Post-Doc also seem suitable to do a second PhD in computer Science (while my current PhD is in Mechanical Engineering). Of course I would have to be an external advisor from the CS department, but i think that is manageable, since i already have some publications in the field of one of their groups and some positive informal contact to one of the Professors there. Also i feel confident that i wont need to much of their time for guidance since i already have the experience of the first PhD.

My reasons to be more inclined towards a second PhD. instead of a Habilitation are that i think i will get bored of my current field in a couple of years, and the second PhD seems to give e a better chance to change fields later. On the other hand i do not know any people who did something like that. And i can not really predict the consequences or reaction of such a unconventional route. And i also do not want to freak out my new boss by mentioning this idea, if the majority of you would consider it as very inappropriate.

What are the pros and cons of extending your research field by doing a second PhD in another direction stead of deepening while doing a Habilitation in the same field? Are there any big disadvantages for the Professor of the department which employs me which i maybe overlooked?

I just started a 3 year Post-Doc position at an engineering department at an German University. The Professor here, informally asked about my ambitions to do a Habilitation. I know that is the common route at least in several European countries in the direction of a permanent faculty position. However the planned activities, and research topics for the Post-Doc also seem suitable to do a second PhD in computer Science (while my current PhD is in Mechanical Engineering). Of course I would have to be an external advisor from the CS department, but i think that is manageable, since i already have some publications in the field of one of their groups and some positive informal contact to one of the Professors there. Also i feel confident that i wont need to much of their time for guidance since i already have the experience of the first PhD.

My reasons to be more inclined towards a second PhD. instead of a Habilitation are that i think i will get bored of my current field in a couple of years, and the second PhD seems to give e a better chance to change fields later. On the other hand i do not know any people who did something like that. And i can not really predict the consequences or reaction of such a unconventional route. And i also do not want to freak out my new boss by mentioning this idea, if the majority of you would consider it as very inappropriate.

What are the pros and cons of extending your research field by doing a second PhD in another direction stead of deepening while doing a Habilitation in the same field? Are there any big disadvantages for the Professor of the department which employs me which i maybe overlooked?

EDIT: The current Position is in Germany. Although i would be interested in staying in Germany, i would also like to hear about perspectives on this for other countries. That also makes the value of the question more general.

1
source | link