Skip to main content
edited body
Source Link
Wrzlprmft
  • 65k
  • 18
  • 199
  • 306

I am the author of a 12-page double-column manuscript submitted to IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics. Here is the record of the updates within the journal online system, corresponding to the aforementioned manuscript:

  1. Submission Finalization: 7th Aug. 2015

  2. Under Review: 11th Aug. 2015

  3. Awaiting EIC Decision: 16th Sep. 2015

The Journaljournal has declared that the authors might expect the result between 8 up to 10 weeks after the submission. But how is it possible to review a 12-page manuscript with a 6-page supplementary material just within one month?

With a full sense of anxiety, I might think that it would be a sinister sign for the early rejection of the manuscript.

Does anybody have any experience with this journal or similar transaction ones, with such very short review-to-result time interval, to evaluate my situation?

I am the author of a 12-page double-column manuscript submitted to IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics. Here is the record of the updates within the journal online system, corresponding to the aforementioned manuscript:

  1. Submission Finalization: 7th Aug. 2015

  2. Under Review: 11th Aug. 2015

  3. Awaiting EIC Decision: 16th Sep. 2015

The Journal has declared that the authors might expect the result between 8 up to 10 weeks after the submission. But how is it possible to review a 12-page manuscript with a 6-page supplementary material just within one month?

With a full sense of anxiety, I might think that it would be a sinister sign for the early rejection of the manuscript.

Does anybody have any experience with this journal or similar transaction ones, with such very short review-to-result time interval, to evaluate my situation?

I am the author of a 12-page double-column manuscript submitted to IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics. Here is the record of the updates within the journal online system, corresponding to the aforementioned manuscript:

  1. Submission Finalization: 7th Aug. 2015

  2. Under Review: 11th Aug. 2015

  3. Awaiting EIC Decision: 16th Sep. 2015

The journal has declared that the authors might expect the result between 8 up to 10 weeks after the submission. But how is it possible to review a 12-page manuscript with a 6-page supplementary material just within one month?

With a full sense of anxiety, I might think that it would be a sinister sign for the early rejection of the manuscript.

Does anybody have any experience with this journal or similar transaction ones, with such very short review-to-result time interval, to evaluate my situation?

Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackAcademia/status/644714241619042304
deleted 60 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
Wrzlprmft
  • 65k
  • 18
  • 199
  • 306

Is it possible to make a decision upon a transaction manuscript just within 1a month?

I am the author of a 12-page double-column manuscript submitted to the IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics journal.IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics. Here is the record of the updates within the journal online system, corresponding to the aforementioned manuscript:

  1. Submission Finalization: 7th Aug. 2015

  2. Under Review: 11th Aug. 2015

  3. Awaiting EIC Decision: 1616th Sep. 2015

The Journal has declared that the authors might expect the result between 8 up to 10 weeks after the submission... But how on earth is it possible to review a transaction 12-page manuscript with a 6-page supplementary material just within one month?!...

With a full sense of anxiety, I might think that it would be a sinister sign for the early rejection of the manuscript...

Does anybody have any experience with this journal or similar transaction ones, with such very short review-to-result time interval, to evaluate my situation?...

Thanks in advance

Is it possible to make a decision upon a transaction manuscript just within 1 month?

I am the author of a 12-page double-column manuscript submitted to the IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics journal. Here is the record of the updates within the journal online system, corresponding to the aforementioned manuscript:

  1. Submission Finalization: 7th Aug. 2015

  2. Under Review: 11th Aug. 2015

  3. Awaiting EIC Decision: 16 Sep. 2015

The Journal has declared that the authors might expect the result between 8 up to 10 weeks after the submission... But how on earth is possible to review a transaction 12-page manuscript with a 6-page supplementary material just within one month?!...

With a full sense of anxiety, I might think that it would be a sinister sign for the early rejection of the manuscript...

Does anybody have any experience with this journal or similar transaction ones, with such very short review-to-result time interval, to evaluate my situation?...

Thanks in advance

Is it possible to make a decision upon a manuscript just within a month?

I am the author of a 12-page double-column manuscript submitted to IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics. Here is the record of the updates within the journal online system, corresponding to the aforementioned manuscript:

  1. Submission Finalization: 7th Aug. 2015

  2. Under Review: 11th Aug. 2015

  3. Awaiting EIC Decision: 16th Sep. 2015

The Journal has declared that the authors might expect the result between 8 up to 10 weeks after the submission. But how is it possible to review a 12-page manuscript with a 6-page supplementary material just within one month?

With a full sense of anxiety, I might think that it would be a sinister sign for the early rejection of the manuscript.

Does anybody have any experience with this journal or similar transaction ones, with such very short review-to-result time interval, to evaluate my situation?

Source Link
user41207
user41207

Is it possible to make a decision upon a transaction manuscript just within 1 month?

I am the author of a 12-page double-column manuscript submitted to the IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics journal. Here is the record of the updates within the journal online system, corresponding to the aforementioned manuscript:

  1. Submission Finalization: 7th Aug. 2015

  2. Under Review: 11th Aug. 2015

  3. Awaiting EIC Decision: 16 Sep. 2015

The Journal has declared that the authors might expect the result between 8 up to 10 weeks after the submission... But how on earth is possible to review a transaction 12-page manuscript with a 6-page supplementary material just within one month?!...

With a full sense of anxiety, I might think that it would be a sinister sign for the early rejection of the manuscript...

Does anybody have any experience with this journal or similar transaction ones, with such very short review-to-result time interval, to evaluate my situation?...

Thanks in advance