17 edited tags
| link
16 fixed a few typos and improved for Q&A format
source | link

As you might see from my history I dontdon't have a good relationship with my advisor. Recently we wrote a journal paper together based on my thesis. I wrote the introduction, analysis and the description of the app we had developed for our research. In crude terms, I wrote 15 pages of the 23 page journal paper. My advisor told me that she had submitted our draft was submitted to this journal three weeks ago, yet I never recievedreceived any notification from the journal that I was listed as author or co-author. Now this is the journal: Link to PDF.

According to the guidelines, if the co-author is not registered with the journal, histheir email should be provided. Its quite obvious I should have recievedreceived an confirmation email and BTW my advisor only has my .edu email so there is no way she could have used another email address could have been used. I have written ana journal paper to IEEE as co-author before and I had received an confirmatory email saying I was listed as co-author. I am afraid of confronting my advisor about this as I need herco-operation to graduate and in my thesis defense. But, but I was curious to know if I will get an email if I am listed as co-author. And more? More importantly, should I be listed as author or co-author in this case, when the work is based on my thesis and I wrote most of the paper?

Edit: So I called the 18001-800 number and when I told them the submitter's last name (my advisor) and the paper title, they confirmed that my advisor was listed as sole author. They told me that they had to unsubmitun-submit and resubmit the journal paper to add me as co-author and they gave me contact of an Univ.a University professor for further inquiries. I have all the email proof of my work (for instance emails where my advisor asks me to write intro and I would reply with the intro text attached and so on). I am seriously upset right now. I have my thesis defense in December and I fear that if I confront my advisor, shethings will screw me up. Can you guys please please advise on what I should do right now?

Edit PS: So i I was told that iI am listed in Acknowledgement section in the end, which is completely unfair. The Deciding officer (it seems he is the final authority in these cases and RIO reports to him) at my UnivUniversity is the vice president, who was my advisor's PhD Advisor half a decade ago. They are both from same city of a foreign country and are close family friends. Rumor has it that the Vice President rejected multiple highly qualified candidates to get my advisor for Asst. Prof. Position. All my friends are asking me to drop it because I dontdon't have many bullets to go after them, but they can completely screw me up or set me up for something if I go against "one of their own". I am still evaluating what to do.

**Edit 11/3/13PPS: Thank you guys for all your advice. Even though I don't know any of you personally, you were very kind in giving me your time and advice. I cannot thank you all enough. I spoke with a full professor in another dept.deptartment in Engineering. He asked me to stay put till December until the paper is published. He was of opinion that the UnivUniversity is a big cesspool and they only way to clean it is to "get the people" who are doing this publicly and shame them. IDKI do not know if I am being used as pawn right now in University politics or what I should do. I spoke with other people too and all they said was "Is not getting an authorship on journal worth more than not earning the degree". It seems sole authorship does carry extra weight age in front of tenure committee. The whole situation has completely shattered my faith in academics. And, and the fact that I am part of a state university makes this even more depressing. And BTWBy the way, one of the two editors of this journal was on advisor's PhD committee. So many people have advised me not to contact any of them. In academicsacademia everybody seems to know everybody, infactin fact it seems more like a cult. I am just doing a Masters now, I always had plans to do PhD and explore my curiosities and see what I can achieve with perseverance, hard work and to test my mental capabilities to their limit, but I am done. I quit. I never felt so depressed for a very long time. AcademicsAcademia these days seems to run by industry practitioners who had previous experience at corporate politics and are good at it or by businessman who wear good clothes, have good people skills and just show off while delegating all the work to GRAs and underlings. And, and that's not what I am and will never be. **

As you might see from my history I dont have a good relationship with my advisor. Recently we wrote a journal paper together based on my thesis. I wrote the introduction, analysis and the description of the app we had developed for our research. In crude terms, I wrote 15 pages of the 23 page journal paper. My advisor told me that she had submitted our draft to this journal three weeks ago, yet I never recieved any notification from the journal that I was listed as author or co-author. Now this is the journal: Link to PDF.

According to the guidelines, if the co-author is not registered with the journal, his email should be provided. Its quite obvious I should have recieved an confirmation email and BTW my advisor only has my .edu email so there is no way she could have used another email address. I have written an journal paper to IEEE as co-author before and I had received an confirmatory email saying I was listed as co-author. I am afraid of confronting my advisor about this as I need her to graduate and in my thesis defense. But I was curious to know if I will get an email if I am listed as co-author. And more importantly, should I be listed as author or co-author in this case, when the work is based on my thesis and I wrote most of the paper?

Edit: So I called the 1800 number and when I told them the submitter's last name (my advisor) and the paper title, they confirmed that my advisor was listed as sole author. They told me that they had to unsubmit and resubmit the journal paper to add me as co-author and they gave me contact of an Univ. professor for further inquiries. I have all email proof of my work (for instance emails where my advisor asks me to write intro and I would reply with the intro text attached and so on). I am seriously upset right now. I have my thesis defense in December and I fear that if I confront my advisor, she will screw me up. Can you guys please advise on what I should do right now?

Edit: So i was told that i am listed in Acknowledgement section in the end, which is completely unfair. The Deciding officer (it seems he is the final authority in these cases and RIO reports to him) at my Univ is the vice president, who was my advisor's PhD Advisor half a decade ago. They are both from same city of a foreign country and are close family friends. Rumor has it that the Vice President rejected multiple highly qualified candidates to get my advisor for Asst. Prof. Position. All my friends are asking me to drop it because I dont have many bullets to go after them, but they can completely screw me up or set me up for something if I go against "one of their own". I am still evaluating what to do.

**Edit 11/3/13: Thank you guys for all your advice. Even though I don't know any of you personally, you were very kind in giving me your time and advice. I cannot thank you all enough. I spoke with a full professor in another dept. in Engineering. He asked me to stay put till December until the paper is published. He was of opinion that the Univ is a big cesspool and they only way to clean it is to "get the people" who are doing this publicly and shame them. IDK if I am being used as pawn right now in University politics or what I should do. I spoke with other people too and all they said was "Is not getting an authorship on journal worth more than not earning the degree". It seems sole authorship does carry extra weight age in front of tenure committee. The whole situation has completely shattered my faith in academics. And the fact that I am part of state university makes this even more depressing. And BTW one of the two editors of this journal was on advisor's PhD committee. So many people have advised me not to contact any of them. In academics everybody seems to know everybody, infact it seems more like a cult. I am just doing Masters now, I always had plans to do PhD and explore my curiosities and see what I can achieve with perseverance, hard work and to test my mental capabilities to their limit, but I am done. I quit. I never felt so depressed for a very long time. Academics these days seems to run by industry practitioners who had previous experience at corporate politics and are good at it or by businessman who wear good clothes, have good people skills and just show off while delegating all the work to GRAs and underlings. And that's not what I am and will never be. **

As you might see from my history I don't have a good relationship with my advisor. Recently we wrote a journal paper together based on my thesis. I wrote the introduction, analysis and the description of the app we had developed for our research. In crude terms, I wrote 15 pages of the 23 page journal paper. My advisor told me that our draft was submitted to this journal three weeks ago, yet I never received any notification from the journal that I was listed as author or co-author.

According to the guidelines, if the co-author is not registered with the journal, their email should be provided. Its quite obvious I should have received an confirmation email and my advisor only has my .edu email so there is no way another email address could have been used. I have written a journal paper to IEEE as co-author before and I had received an confirmatory email saying I was listed as co-author. I am afraid of confronting my advisor about this as I need co-operation to graduate and in my thesis defense, but I was curious to know if I will get an email if I am listed as co-author? More importantly, should I be listed as author or co-author in this case, when the work is based on my thesis and I wrote most of the paper?

I called the 1-800 number and when I told them the submitter's last name (my advisor) and the paper title, they confirmed that my advisor was listed as sole author. They told me that they had to un-submit and resubmit the journal paper to add me as co-author and they gave me contact of a University professor for further inquiries. I have all the email proof of my work (for instance emails where my advisor asks me to write intro and I would reply with the intro text attached and so on). I am seriously upset right now. I have my thesis defense in December and I fear that if I confront my advisor, things will screw up. Can you please advise on what I should do right now?

PS: I was told that I am listed in Acknowledgement section in the end, which is completely unfair. The Deciding officer (it seems he is the final authority in these cases and RIO reports to him) at my University is the vice president, who was my advisor's PhD Advisor half a decade ago. They are both from same city of a foreign country and are close family friends. Rumor has it that the Vice President rejected multiple highly qualified candidates to get my advisor for Asst. Prof. Position. All my friends are asking me to drop it because I don't have many bullets to go after them, but they can completely screw me up or set me up for something if I go against "one of their own". I am still evaluating what to do.

PPS: Thank you for all your advice. Even though I don't know any of you personally, you were very kind in giving me your time and advice. I cannot thank you all enough. I spoke with a full professor in another deptartment in Engineering. He asked me to stay put till December until the paper is published. He was of opinion that the University is a big cesspool and they only way to clean it is to "get the people" who are doing this publicly and shame them. I do not know if I am being used as pawn right now in University politics or what I should do. I spoke with other people too and all they said was "Is not getting an authorship on journal worth more than not earning the degree". It seems sole authorship does carry extra weight age in front of tenure committee. The whole situation has completely shattered my faith in academics, and the fact that I am part of a state university makes this even more depressing. By the way, one of the two editors of this journal was on advisor's PhD committee. So many people have advised me not to contact any of them. In academia everybody seems to know everybody, in fact it seems more like a cult. I am just doing a Masters now, I always had plans to do PhD and explore my curiosities and see what I can achieve with perseverance, hard work and to test my mental capabilities to their limit, but I am done. I quit. I never felt so depressed for a very long time. Academia these days seems to run by industry practitioners who had previous experience at corporate politics and are good at it or by businessman who wear good clothes, have good people skills and just show off while delegating all the work to GRAs and underlings, and that's not what I am and will never be.

15 punctuation
source | link

As you might see from my history I dont have a good relationship with my advisor. Recently we wrote ana journal paper together based on my thesis. I wrote the introduction, analysis and the description of the app we had developed for our research. In crude terms, I wrote 15 pages of the 23 page journal paper. My advisor told me that she had submitted our draft to this journal three weeks ago, yet I never recieved any notification from the journal that I was listed as author or co-author. Now this is the journal: Link to PDF.

Edit: So i was told that i am listed in Acknowledgement section in the end, which is completely unfair  . The Deciding officer (it seems he is the final authority in these cases and RIO reports to him)at at my Univ is the vice president  ,who who was my advisor's PHDPhD Advisor half a decade ago. They are both from same city of a foreign country and are close family friends. Rumor has it that the Vice President rejected multiple highly qualified candidates to get my advisor for Asst. Prof. Position. All my friends are asking me to drop it because iI dont have many bullets to go after them  ,but but they can completely screw up me up or set me up for something if iI go against "one of their own"  . I am still evaluating what to do.

**Edit 11/3/13: ThankyouThank you guys for all your advice. Even though i dontI don't know any of you personally, you were very kind in giving me your time and advice.I I cannot thank you all enough. I spoke with ana full professor in another dept. in Engineering. He asked me to stay put till December until the paper is published. He was of opinion that the Univ is a big cesspool and they only way to clean it is to "get the people" who are doing this publicly and shame them. IDK if iI am being used as pawn right now in University politics or what iI should do. I spoke with other people too and all they said was "Is not getting an authorship on journal worth more than not earning the degree". It seems sole authorship does carry extra weight age in front of tenure committee. The whole situation has completely shattered my faith in academics. And the fact that iI am part of state university makes this even more depressing. And BTW one of the two editors of this journal was on advisor's PHDPhD committee. So many people have advised me not to contact any of them. In academics everybody seems to know everybody  ,infact infact it seems more like a cult  .I I am just doing Masters now  ,i I always had plans to do PHD anPhD and explore my curiosities and see what iI can achieve with perseverance  , hard work and to test my mental capabilities to their limit, but iI am done  .I I quit.I I never felt so depressed for a very long time. Academics these days seems to run by industry practitioners who had previous experience at corporate politics and are good at it or by businessman who wear good clothes,have have good people skills and just show off while delegating all the work to GRAs and underlings.And And that's not what iI am and will never be. **

As you might see from my history I dont have a good relationship with my advisor. Recently we wrote an journal paper together based on my thesis. I wrote the introduction, analysis and the description of the app we had developed for our research. In crude terms, I wrote 15 pages of the 23 page journal paper. My advisor told me that she had submitted our draft to this journal three weeks ago, yet I never recieved any notification from the journal that I was listed as author or co-author. Now this is the journal: Link to PDF.

Edit: So i was told that i am listed in Acknowledgement section in the end, which is completely unfair  . The Deciding officer (it seems he is final authority in these cases and RIO reports to him)at my Univ is the vice president  ,who was my advisor's PHD Advisor half a decade ago. They are both from same city of a foreign country and are close family friends. Rumor has it that the Vice President rejected multiple highly qualified candidates to get my advisor for Asst. Prof. Position. All my friends are asking me to drop it because i dont have many bullets to go after them  ,but they can completely screw up me or set me up for something if i go against "one of their own"  . I am still evaluating what to do.

**Edit 11/3/13: Thankyou guys for all your advice. Even though i dont know any of you personally, you were very kind in giving me your time and advice.I cannot thank you all enough. I spoke with an full professor in another dept. in Engineering. He asked me to stay put till December until the paper is published. He was of opinion that the Univ is a big cesspool and they only way to clean it is to "get the people" who are doing this publicly and shame them. IDK if i am being used as pawn right now in University politics or what i should do. I spoke with other people too and all they said was "Is not getting an authorship on journal worth more than not earning the degree". It seems sole authorship does carry extra weight age in front of tenure committee. The whole situation has completely shattered my faith in academics. And the fact that i am part of state university makes this even more depressing. And BTW one of the two editors of this journal was on advisor's PHD committee. So many people have advised me not to contact any of them. In academics everybody seems to know everybody  ,infact it seems more like a cult  .I am just doing Masters now  ,i always had plans to do PHD an explore my curiosities and see what i can achieve with perseverance  , hard work and to test my mental capabilities to their limit but i am done  .I quit.I never felt so depressed for a very long time. Academics these days seems to run by industry practitioners who had previous experience at corporate politics and are good at it or by businessman who wear good clothes,have good people skills and just show off while delegating all the work to GRAs and underlings.And that's not what i am and will never be. **

As you might see from my history I dont have a good relationship with my advisor. Recently we wrote a journal paper together based on my thesis. I wrote the introduction, analysis and the description of the app we had developed for our research. In crude terms, I wrote 15 pages of the 23 page journal paper. My advisor told me that she had submitted our draft to this journal three weeks ago, yet I never recieved any notification from the journal that I was listed as author or co-author. Now this is the journal: Link to PDF.

Edit: So i was told that i am listed in Acknowledgement section in the end, which is completely unfair. The Deciding officer (it seems he is the final authority in these cases and RIO reports to him) at my Univ is the vice president, who was my advisor's PhD Advisor half a decade ago. They are both from same city of a foreign country and are close family friends. Rumor has it that the Vice President rejected multiple highly qualified candidates to get my advisor for Asst. Prof. Position. All my friends are asking me to drop it because I dont have many bullets to go after them, but they can completely screw me up or set me up for something if I go against "one of their own". I am still evaluating what to do.

**Edit 11/3/13: Thank you guys for all your advice. Even though I don't know any of you personally, you were very kind in giving me your time and advice. I cannot thank you all enough. I spoke with a full professor in another dept. in Engineering. He asked me to stay put till December until the paper is published. He was of opinion that the Univ is a big cesspool and they only way to clean it is to "get the people" who are doing this publicly and shame them. IDK if I am being used as pawn right now in University politics or what I should do. I spoke with other people too and all they said was "Is not getting an authorship on journal worth more than not earning the degree". It seems sole authorship does carry extra weight age in front of tenure committee. The whole situation has completely shattered my faith in academics. And the fact that I am part of state university makes this even more depressing. And BTW one of the two editors of this journal was on advisor's PhD committee. So many people have advised me not to contact any of them. In academics everybody seems to know everybody, infact it seems more like a cult. I am just doing Masters now, I always had plans to do PhD and explore my curiosities and see what I can achieve with perseverance, hard work and to test my mental capabilities to their limit, but I am done. I quit. I never felt so depressed for a very long time. Academics these days seems to run by industry practitioners who had previous experience at corporate politics and are good at it or by businessman who wear good clothes, have good people skills and just show off while delegating all the work to GRAs and underlings. And that's not what I am and will never be. **

14 added 62 characters in body
source | link
13 added 83 characters in body
source | link
12 added 140 characters in body
source | link
11 added 1307 characters in body
source | link
10 edited tags
| link
9 added 613 characters in body
source | link
8 edited title
| link
7 language edits
source | link
6 Punctuation and other typographic changes
| link
5 Punctuation and other typographic changes
source | link
    Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackAcademia/status/395078432406900736
4 deleted 525 characters in body
source | link
3 added 524 characters in body
source | link
2 added 524 characters in body
source | link
1
source | link