Academia Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for academics and those enrolled in higher education. It only takes a minute to sign up.

Sign up to join this community

Anybody can ask a question

Anybody can answer

The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Explore our Questions

more tags

Active 2 Bountied Hot Week Month

44

votes

5

answers

7k

views

Declining a paper review after accepting it and seeing the manuscript

peer-review journals

answered 2 days ago Karl 1,448

0

votes

1

answer

161

views

Whether to add co-author who helped in modifying a journal paper based on a peer-review feedback?

publications peer-review coauthors

modified Dec 12 at 2:48 Jeromy Anglim 18.1k

2

votes

1

answer

309

views

What are the arguments for “reviewers see each other's identities” conference reviews?

peer-review

modified Dec 11 at 18:25 lighthouse keeper 11.5k

0

votes

2

answers

79

views

Removing a part of a paper during major revision

publications peer-review writing

answered Dec 10 at 22:26 Wetenschaap 1,166

4

votes

1

answer

159

views

What merits acceptance for rapid publication in letter format?

publications peer-review paper-submission

modified Dec 3 at 8:54 ocspro 41

-1

votes

0

answers

130

views

How often does one review praise the writing quality while a second review criticizes the writing quality?

peer-review writing

modified Dec 3 at 6:36 Rebecca J. Stones 8,751

0

votes

1

answer

73

views

resumbitted paper proper citation

citations peer-review

modified Nov 30 at 17:33 J. Tylka 398

0

votes

1

answer

90

views

Why Elsevier Journals don't change status of a paper?

peer-review

modified Nov 30 at 8:59 Tripartio 3,863

2

votes

1

answer

85

views

Ask clarification to reviewer of paper

publications peer-review

modified Nov 28 at 12:41 Tejas Shetty 523

0

votes

2

answers

161

views

Referees ask for more content but this lengthens the paper dramatically

publications peer-review journals etiquette

answered Nov 26 at 1:11 Buffy 101k

1

vote

3

answers

137

views

When and how often is an associate editor not starting review process?

peer-review journals paper-submission editors

answered Nov 25 at 2:32 Allure 58.4k

0

votes

1

answer

40

views

Definitions of IEEE RAS review “dimensions”

peer-review ieee

answered Nov 24 at 20:07 J. Tylka 398

3

votes

2

answers

61

views

How to evaluate a paper with concurrent results

publications peer-review conference

answered Nov 24 at 18:28 Buffy 101k

23

votes

6

answers

5k

views

I peer reviewed a paper and found it to be sound - technically and language-wise. How should I write the review report?

publications peer-review

answered Nov 23 at 13:13 Wrzlprmft♦ 39.4k

Browse more Questions

Academia Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled