Academia Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for academics and those enrolled in higher education. It only takes a minute to sign up.

Sign up to join this community

Anybody can ask a question

Anybody can answer

The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Explore our Questions

more tags

Active Hot Week Month

1

vote

2

answers

108

views

How to respond to receiving a duplicate list of corrections

peer-review paper-submission

modified 10 hours ago Buffy 115k

6

votes

2

answers

2k

views

Editor's mail with no reviewer's comment

publications peer-review editors

modified 13 hours ago Antonio 1

2

votes

1

answer

85

views

How to proceed when one peer reviewer gives a much lower score than the others but provides no negative feedback?

peer-review projects feedback

answered yesterday Buffy 115k

2

votes

2

answers

104

views

Is it normal for an Associate Editor to keep the paper for over a month after the reviews are done?

peer-review ieee

modified 2 days ago 6005 741

139

votes

1

answer

62k

views

What does the typical workflow of a journal look like?

publications journals peer-review paper-submission journal-workflow

modified Feb 24 at 15:33 Doubt 229

20

votes

4

answers

21k

views

Editor rejected my paper stating that reviewers had refused to review it long after submission; How can I understand what is wrong with my paper?

publications peer-review rejection

modified Feb 23 at 15:54 user119799 11

2

votes

1

answer

103

views

Citation problems, in supporting general information, what kind of paper should I cite?

publications citations peer-review

modified Feb 22 at 12:00 Community♦ 1

26

votes

2

answers

16k

views

How to write a rebuttal for a conference

publications conference peer-review

modified Feb 21 at 9:49 Skipper07 581

1

vote

1

answer

109

views

Are summarized reviewer comments a thing?

publications peer-review editors

modified Feb 20 at 16:07 OnMyWayOut 23

1

vote

2

answers

167

views

Weird changes to status of paper

publications peer-review journal-workflow

modified Feb 19 at 17:20 Wolfgang Bangerth 44.5k

1

vote

2

answers

285

views

How to politely explain editor is wrong

publications peer-review etiquette editors

modified Feb 19 at 1:05 Ben - Reinstate Monica 18.8k

47

votes

3

answers

4k

views

Is there any evidence that double blind peer review systems are beneficial?

peer-review anonymity

modified Feb 17 at 13:21 Matteo 2,481

1

vote

3

answers

219

views

How to address an Editor if I have new proof techniques of old results?

publications research-process peer-review editors

answered Feb 16 at 23:20 Dan Romik 105k

3

votes

3

answers

297

views

What should I do if I am asked to review a paper that should have been reviewed by an ethics committee, but was not?

answered Feb 15 at 15:18 vonbrand 9,100

Browse more Questions

Academia Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled