Join us in building a kind, collaborative learning community via our updated Code of Conduct.

Academia Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for academics and those enrolled in higher education. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up

Here's how it works:

Anybody can ask a question
Anybody can answer
The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Top Questions

active hot week month

170

votes

15

answers

28k

views

How can I convince graduate students in China to not copy/paste from the Internet into their research papers?

publications plagiarism china

answered yesterday paul garrett 47.6k

51

votes

8

answers

21k

views

Why do most scientists think Brexit is bad for British science?

united-kingdom politics

modified Aug 2 at 10:58 avid 4,801

52

votes

15

answers

16k

views

How do so many people here on Academia.SE, and in general, afford lavish higher education programs?

graduate-admissions graduate-school funding united-states

modified Aug 8 at 1:16 eykanal♦ 40.8k

96

votes

9

answers

23k

views

Why do Americans care so much about recommendation letters?

united-states recommendation-letter

answered Aug 3 at 23:43 Fomite 46k

67

votes

13

answers

17k

views

How should an advisor handle an underperforming PhD student?

phd research-process advisor

modified Jul 29 at 1:17 Peter Mortensen 280

46

votes

7

answers

18k

views

Using rage faces in presentation

etiquette presentation

modified Aug 10 at 3:38 qsp 10.1k

53

votes

10

answers

20k

views

Telling PhD supervisor I published a paper about my thesis without telling them or listing them as authors? [closed]

publications thesis professors

modified Jul 20 at 18:37 Ben I. 132

33

votes

9

answers

12k

views

How to query gender in a multiple-choice poll/survey?

ethics gender survey-research

answered Aug 1 at 0:29 ahiijny 186

70

votes

7

answers

9k

views

How to avoid a hostile takeover of first authorship during medical leave?

authorship

modified 7 hours ago Industrademic 1,318

57

votes

13

answers

12k

views

Does being a top-tier university always imply unhealthy graduate student environments?

phd community

answered Aug 3 at 2:00 darij grinberg 1,539

58

votes

9

answers

9k

views

Why is peer review so random?

peer-review

modified 4 hours ago Wrzlprmft♦ 31.8k

31

votes

15

answers

13k

views

Dr. ‹First Name›: a good nickname or a “professional cancer”?

phd united-states titles personal-name

modified Aug 7 at 16:56 Ethan Bolker 3,032

43

votes

5

answers

9k

views

Avoiding publishing in a particular journal without bringing up politics

publications ethics authorship reputation

modified Jul 23 at 11:23 Nemo 661

37

votes

12

answers

9k

views

How to address in-group bullying without compromising PhD/career?

phd academic-life supervision group-dynamics research-group

answered Jul 25 at 7:01 Güray Hatipoğlu 832

54

votes

5

answers

16k

views

Does having an article retracted due to professor's ethical misconduct mean my career is over?

ethics plagiarism self-plagiarism research-misconduct retraction

answered Jul 29 at 13:23 Philip Oakley 218

34

votes

5

answers

7k

views

Should I decline a request to tutor a class I will be taking?

tutoring

answered Jul 27 at 16:48 B. Goddard 3,629

34

votes

5

answers

11k

views

Would an honest researcher actually have to pay back their salary?

legal-issues salary

modified Jul 31 at 12:54 Buffy 10.5k

29

votes

8

answers

7k

views

Do postdocs still take courses?

graduate-school computer-science united-states postdocs

answered Aug 8 at 14:05 hdg204 141

37

votes

6

answers

8k

views

Are best-paper awards for conferences rigged/pre-decided?

conference awards

modified Jul 25 at 21:12 Sjaffry 506

20

votes

6

answers

8k

views

Is pasting an excerpt from Wikipedia in a paper without reference plagiarism?

publications citations peer-review

modified Aug 10 at 3:42 Scott 122

31

votes

7

answers

8k

views

Why is it disadvantageous in graduate admissions to have a higher degree?

graduate-admissions second-degree

modified 2 days ago Allure 13.7k

25

votes

4

answers

6k

views

Is it reasonable for an author to withdraw an accepted paper because they have since done better work?

publications withdraw

answered 2 days ago David Richerby 26k

16

votes

7

answers

6k

views

Why don't authors include in their publications the duration of the research?

publications

answered Jul 27 at 2:00 user96454 31

44

votes

5

answers

10k

views

Should I inform authorities of someone falsely claiming a non-existing PhD?

phd ethics

modified Aug 3 at 22:35 Curdflappers 3

14

votes

9

answers

6k

views

Is it possible to ask the professor to check assignment before submitting?

professors code homework programming

answered Jul 23 at 18:36 BlueRaja - Danny Pflughoeft 516

13

votes

5

answers

8k

views

Why does the UK produce so many research papers?

publications

modified Jul 25 at 20:04 Jack Aidley 7,656

30

votes

5

answers

10k

views

Multiple accounts of plagiarism (?) during literature study: are my standards too high or should I take action?

citations plagiarism

modified Aug 7 at 13:58 Bram 151

38

votes

4

answers

8k

views

Is Mx. the default title for Male non-phd holders?

titles gender

answered Jul 20 at 13:03 lly 418

15

votes

5

answers

6k

views

Proving authorship when name in publications does not match name in passport

publications personal-name

modified Aug 7 at 8:59 Qsigma 107

6

votes

5

answers

6k

views

If I got 1.0 for Master thesis in Germany, can it be summa cum laude in my CV?

masters cv grades germany

modified Jul 23 at 10:25 Konrad Rudolph 2,900

19

votes

5

answers

3k

views

Which is more valued, first authorship articles or the number of articles produced?

publications phd graduate-school postdocs bioinformatics

modified Aug 10 at 11:37 Llopis 687

24

votes

5

answers

4k

views

Do author name(s) dominate the content of the paper?

journals peer-review

modified 15 hours ago einpoklum 20k

23

votes

3

answers

5k

views

How to get lab resources back from a post-doc who resigned while on vacation and not coming back?

united-states postdocs legal-issues quitting

modified Jul 31 at 23:31 V2Blast 125

21

votes

3

answers

4k

views

Conflict of interest as a referee?

peer-review conflict-of-interest

answered Jul 31 at 13:30 David Richerby 26k

32

votes

3

answers

4k

views

Co-authors on a study have cut communication, what can be done?

publications

modified 16 hours ago gerrit 26.8k

26

votes

4

answers

5k

views

Can a department renege on a student's “guaranteed funding”?

graduate-school funding united-states

answered Aug 9 at 8:11 einpoklum 20k

23

votes

8

answers

2k

views

Is it unfair for paper circumstances to play a role in the review of the paper? [closed]

peer-review ethics

answered Jul 28 at 17:11 Sascha 1,345

46

votes

4

answers

8k

views

Meeting dishonest ex-supervisors at large international conference — Should one speak out?

ethics postdocs emotional-responses china scams

modified Aug 10 at 3:05 Scientist 4,920

15

votes

2

answers

4k

views

Should I share a scan of my published paper with an academic in my field?

publications

modified Jul 25 at 22:21 corey979 2,728

25

votes

4

answers

4k

views

How should I approach job materials for a lateral move entirely for two-body reasons?

faculty-application two-body-problem

answered Aug 9 at 1:20 Ethan Bolker 3,032

12

votes

5

answers

3k

views

Are journal papers published in journals more useful than arXiv papers when applying for a postdoc?

publications job-search arxiv

modified Jul 17 at 7:41 Stephan Kolassa 26.8k

18

votes

4

answers

4k

views

How to reply to unprofessional negative review from a journal? [closed]

publications peer-review paper-submission

modified Jul 31 at 8:22 Wrzlprmft♦ 31.8k

20

votes

3

answers

3k

views

Is it acceptable for a referee to suggest changing “theorem” into “proposition”?

mathematics peer-review etiquette

modified Jul 20 at 5:54 Community♦ 1

16

votes

2

answers

3k

views

Is it appropriate if my former advisor is editor of a journal I submit to?

journals advisor editors conflict-of-interest

answered Jul 30 at 12:12 Buffy 10.5k

-3

votes

8

answers

894

views

Unconventional fonts [closed]

publications formatting

modified Aug 2 at 5:29 Wrzlprmft♦ 31.8k

11

votes

4

answers

4k

views

Is it considered unethical to pay participants differently based on some quality?

ethics irb

answered Jul 24 at 23:24 Trusly 295

10

votes

5

answers

952

views

What are the upsides for British science from Brexit?

united-kingdom politics

answered 2 days ago Industrademic 1,318

35

votes

3

answers

2k

views

Is it possible to publish a deceased relative's unpublished work with them as the author?

publications arxiv online-publication

modified Jul 22 at 12:48 Solar Mike 7,559

Looking for more? Browse the complete list of questions, or popular tags. Help us answer unanswered questions.

Academia Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled