Following ArXiv rules I contacted with an well-known expert in thermodynamics (he is author of a known monograph) we discussed my work during several days and finally he endorsed me. When my work was ready to appear a moderator removed it, alluding to technical problems with my submission (a embedded font problem), although more latter moderators asked me personal and even economic questions! I never answer such questions and forgot the whole issue
The paper is accessible in my page at academia.edu
I have participated in an Essay Contest with another work, and it has been selected as one of the finalists. It is cited here together other three finalist essays.
I submitted this new work to ArXiV, it has been removed and I received the next response:
Your submission has been removed upon a notice from our moderators, who determined it to be inappropriate for arXiv. Please find another forum.
For more information on our moderation policies see:
http: //arxiv. org/help/moderation
-- arXiv moderation
ArXiv already archives several essays submitted to the same Essay contest, such as 1209.0023, 1209.1257, 1211.1917, 1210.3575
Therefore it is not a problem with the Contest or with the format. Notice that only one of above four has been selected as finalist.
According to the moderation policy I cannot ask to moderators about the details on their decision. The excuse is that "moderators are not referees", but this looks a bit childish, because it seems that they are accepting that moderators cannot sustain logically the decisions that they take about others' work.
Would I write to the advisory committee chair? Would I take some other action?